Mike,
Using the image itself as a template to match is possible. In fact it has
been done before. But it suffers from several problems that would also need
solving.
1) Images are 2D. I assume you are also referring to 2D outlines. Real
objects are 3D. So, you're going to have to infer the shape
I accidentally pressed something and it sent it early... this is a finished
version:
Mike,
Using the image itself as a template to match is possible. In fact it has
been done before. But it suffers from several problems that would also need
solving.
1) Images are 2D. I assume you are also
General point: you keep talking as if algorithms *work* for visual AGI - they
don't - they simply haven't. Unless you take a set of objects carefully chosen
to be closely aligned and close in overall form- and then it's not AGI. But in
general the algorithmic patterned approach has been a bust
Mike,
Your claim that you have to reject encoded and simpler descriptions of the
world to solve AGI is unfounded. You can't solve the problems with your
approach either. So, this is argument is going no where. You won't admit
that you're faced with the same problems no matter how you approach it.
Dave:You can't solve the problems with your approach either
This is based on knowledge of what examples? Zero?
I have given you one instance of s.o. [a technologist not a philosopher like
me] who is if only in broad principle, trying to proceed in a non-encoding,
analog-comparison direction.
On Sat, Jul 10, 2010 at 5:02 PM, Mike Tintner tint...@blueyonder.co.ukwrote:
Dave:You can't solve the problems with your approach either
This is based on knowledge of what examples? Zero?
It is based on the fact that you have refused to show how you deal with
uncertainty. You haven't even
David,
Sorry for the slow response.
I agree completely about expectations vs predictions, though I wouldn't use
that terminology to make the distinction (since the two terms are
near-synonyms in English, and I'm not aware of any technical definitions
that are common in the literature). This is
