I vote as follows, and act on behalf of o to vote as follows: > 8288 omd 1.0 Glitteral Endorse the Treasuror. This takes away the requirement to specify the reward amount explicitly in the announcement. Is it too much of a burden on the Treasuror to keep abreast of the ribbons and do the calculations?
> 8296 Aris, G. 1.0 Divergence FOR > 8297 Aris 2.1 Imminent Failure FOR > 8298 Aris, [2] 2.0 Administrative Adjudication v3 AGAINST. Two concerns here. (1) I have no idea what "tracked along with judicial cases" means in terms of practical tracking, and don't think it should be the Arbitor's job (if that's what's meant), and (2) officer discretion should mean that there's some means for a current officer to overrule a past officer (whatever you call reverse precedent where the new takes the place of the old). > 8299 Aris, G. 3.0 The Reset Button v2 AGAINST (as discussed) > 8300 Aris 3.0 Patches AGAINST. I just noticed that it's not at all clear that the identify of the "promulgator" moves with the office. It's also not clear that "an officer" has to be the officer who issues the memorandum, the way it reads, once a particular officer issues a memorandum within eir domain, then *any* officer can do the regulation provided it is pursuant to the memorandum. > 8301 Aris, Jason Cobb 3.0 Consolidated Regulatory Recordkeeping v2 AGAINST. As above, "tracked as part of eir weekly or monthly report in a fashion similar to rules" is confusing, what does "fashion similar" mean, Also this implies it's part of the SLR (weekly?) The point of the SLR is it doesn't include this information. > 8302 Aris 1.5 Generic Petitions PRESENT. Tempted for "against" at the undefined "discretionary power" overlapping with "power" in general (I have no "discretionary power" - my power is 0 unless the rules say so). A better term would be "discretionary actions" or "discretionary abilities". Still, seems like a later-fixable minor confusion and the idea is sound. > 8294 Bernie, twg 3.0 Authorial Intent AGAINST (previously discussed) Thus ends my (and o's) votes for now - no votes on the following, left here for later reference (phew this is taking some time to go through): > 8291 Bernie, [1] 3.0 Interesting Chambers v3.1 > 8292 Bernie, twg 3.0 Self-Ratification Simplification Act > 8295 Bernie, twg, Alexis 3.0 Rewards Reform Act > 8303 Aris, [3] 3.0 Contract Patency v3 > 8304 Bernie, twg, Jason Cobb 3.0 Rewards Reform Act - v1.1 Patch
