Re: DIS: Proto: The Supreme Court

2011-11-09 Thread Ed Murphy
Yally wrote: Supreme cases are a subclass of appeal cases. The specific word subclass potentially runs afoul of exactly one in Rule 991. How about expanding the panel size to five? An appeal concerning any assignment of judgement in a non-appeal case within the past two weeks CAN be

DIS: Proto: The Supreme Court

2011-11-08 Thread Aaron Goldfein
This case would create a new level of appeals, The Supreme Court, which consists of some entitled members and otherwise consists of members that the CotC subjectively determines to be the most suited for the case. I THINK the below proposal should properly inherit appeals issues from appeal cases

Re: DIS: Proto: The Supreme Court

2011-11-08 Thread Pavitra
If a judgement-on-appeal really needs overturning that badly, a new identical CFJ can be called.

Re: DIS: Proto: The Supreme Court

2009-11-25 Thread Ed Murphy
c. wrote: Clerk is a judicial case switch, tracked by the Clerk of the Courts, with values 'CotC' (default) and 'Justiciar'. This would require the CotC to keep a permanent list of cases accepted by the Justiciar (not that that's a big deal, though, compare the Assessor's report

DIS: Proto: The Supreme Court

2009-11-24 Thread comex
Proto: The Supreme Court (AI=2) [Cases can be appealed to the Supreme Court, a fixed (elected) set of three justices. Appeal can be made by announcement but court doesn't have to accept the appeal. If they do, they need to address the issue in detail. Compared to normal appeals, the court has