DIS: collated rules history

2007-03-28 Thread Zefram
Here's an early product of my historical research. I've collated all the history annotations from the rulesets that I've found, and resolved most of the many conflicts between them. The data behind this output includes rule text too, but I'm concentrating on the history logs to provide the

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: CFJ 1608 assigned to Maud

2007-03-28 Thread Ed Murphy
Maud wrote: On 3/23/07, Kerim Aydin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I assign CFJ 1608 to Maud. Text is here: http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2007-January/002784.html I (proto-)judge the statement of CFJ 1608 to be TRUE. Actually, this may be trivially true due

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: CFJ 1608 assigned to Maud

2007-03-28 Thread Michael Slone
On 3/28/07, Ed Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Actually, this may be trivially true due to Rule 2034. If I understand the argument you intend, this would depend on Agorans agreeing not to challenge the vote collector's announcement of results. Admittedly, it might seem bizarre for someone to

DIS: Re: BUS: Motion bug: excess CFJs broken

2007-03-28 Thread Kerim Aydin
Zefram wrote: My intent with the motions was to force assignment of judges regardless of what state the CFJs were in. I'm not at all clear on whether they've been legally judged. I understood that intent, and it should work and force a judicial assignment even after the CotC dismissed the