Re: DIS: A better argument for Unanimous working

2007-01-14 Thread Michael Slone
I wrote: I believe Kelly maintains that we quit playing Agora when it was decided (*not* by me) to handwave away the Annabel issue instead of reconstructing the gamestate. On 1/12/07, Ed Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I object to my Annabel is deemed to have been a separate person all

DIS: A better argument for Unanimous working

2007-01-12 Thread Kerim Aydin
One other aspect of Agoran common custom is that this is a legal game before a logic/mathematical one, and we've used in the past legal reasonableness to sidestep the more trivial paradoxes. Especially true in the current, slimmed-down ruleset. In legal terms, Unanimous means having the

Re: DIS: A better argument for Unanimous working

2007-01-12 Thread Kerim Aydin
I wrote: And if all parties to an agreement have consented, it would substantially abridge the rights of the Players in R101 if we *didn't* assume prima facie that the change was valid. Ps. It's possible, following this argument, that if *all* indices are broken or unordered, then the

Re: DIS: A better argument for Unanimous working

2007-01-12 Thread Michael Slone
On 1/12/07, Kerim Aydin [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: of selecting a reasonable ordering for the index. Who knows, maybe even Kelly would like it. I believe Kelly maintains that we quit playing Agora when it was decided (*not* by me) to handwave away the Annabel issue instead of reconstructing the