Well, if as I understand it, the chain of JUSTICE is (intended to be) as
follows:
Commit a crime -> Someone points eir finger -> Investigator investigates
-> Investigator finds guilty (assume so) -> Investigator imposes the
COLD HAND OF JUSTICE, which is the done by applying a fine.
Everythi
Fines can be levied, surely, per the revised version of CFJ 3736, which
says they CAN, but not by announcement
On Tue, Jun 18, 2019 at 10:13 PM D. Margaux wrote:
> As stated, this CFJ is trivially FALSE because no fine CAN be imposed for
> anything. Maybe there is a different way to pose the CFJ
As stated, this CFJ is trivially FALSE because no fine CAN be imposed for
anything. Maybe there is a different way to pose the CFJ that would be
PARADOXICAL though?
> On Jun 16, 2019, at 1:25 AM, Jason Cobb wrote:
>
> Oooh look, I broke my Oath. How unexpected!
>
> I point my finger at Jason
Gratuitous Argument
The Pledge rule states that "N is 2 unless the pledge explicitly states
otherwise". But it doesn't say what N is when the pledge _does_ explicitly
state otherwise. Therefore, N is indeterminate and there is no explicit
Class for this crime, so it defaults to a base value of 2.
4 matches
Mail list logo
