DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Ed Strange via agora-discussion]

POSITIVE KARMA POGCHAMP

On Sun, Jun 28, 2020 at 11:11 PM Publius Scribonius Scholasticus via
agora-official  wrote:

> Herald's Weekly report
>
> Date of Last Report: 21 June 2020
> Date of This Report: 28 June 2020
>
> Karma  Entity
> -  --
>
> +7 Jason <= SHOGUN
> +6 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
> +5 Aris
>
> -  ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
>
> +3 G.
> +2 omd
> +2 Trigon
> +2 Warrigal
> +1 R. Lee
> +1 Tyler
> -1 Agora
> -1 Bernie
> -1 Gaelan
> -1 o
> -1 Unspecified Behavior [1]
> -2 Rance
> -3 ATMunn
> -3 CuddleBeam
> -4 Baron von Vaderham
> -4 D. Margaux
> -4 Falsifian
> -4 Murphy
>
> -  BELOW -4 LIE THE GAMMAS
>
>  <= HONOURLESS WORM
>
> -  --
> All other entities have 0 Karma.
>
> Notes
> -
> [1] Unspecified Behavior purports to be a player; however, eir identity is
> unspecified.
>
>
> Notices of Honour (2 Years History):
> 
>
> grok (28 June 2020)
> +1 R. Lee (for Being a Good Sport when  faced with a judgment going the
>wrong way and eir fun scam attempt that encouraged a flurry of
>gameplay)
> -1 grok (for neglecting judicial duties and dragging out the scam's
>  denouement)
>
> G. (28 June 2020)
> +1 grok (for delivering a heavy judgement load under pressure)
> -1 G. (for putting you in the situation with rushed Arbitoring)
>
> ATMunn (23 June 2020)
> +1 Agora (Agora has negative karma right now)
> -1 Unspecified Behavior [1] (for being suspicious and mysterious and weird)
>
> Trigon (23 June 2020)
> +1 Jason (roolz)
> -1 Trigon (sux)
>
> R. Lee (22 June 2020)
> +1 Cuddlebeam (making an actually good contract)
> -1 Alexis (inactive with positive honour)
>
> [New Week 22-June]
>
> G. (21 June 2020)
> +1 Falsifian (e ain't no worm).
> -1 G.  (following a not-worm's example)
>
> [time of last report]
>
> Jason (21 June 2020)
> +1 Aris (having to judge my silly CFJs)
> -1 Jason (making Aris's life unnecessarily harder (silly CFJs, missing that
>   the proposal pool draft was backdated))
>
> Aris (19 June 2020)
> +1 Trigon (excellent work as Treasuror during an extremely difficult time)
> -1 Aris (making the Treasuror's life difficult)
>
> Trigon (19 June 2020)
> +1 G. for giving me actual criticism on the format of my report.
> -1 twg for being inactive with positive karma (e should be down to 0 now)
>
> R. Lee (15 June 2020)
> +1 PSS (who holds the most offices and does everything in a timely way.)
> -1 Murphy (missing 3 reports, failing to contest an election or object to
> my
>deputisation, and then fussing about it weeks later)
>
> Falsifian (15 June 2020)
> +1 Jason (for setting the record straight.)
> -1 Falsifian (on behalf of the office of the Registrar, for bad
> recordkeeping
>   in August 2017.)
>
> [New Week 15-June]
>
> Murphy (14 June 2020)
> +1 R. Lee (picking up the slack)
> -1 Murphy (falling behind again)
>
> Trigon (09 June 2020)
> +1 PSS (for eir help proofreading this contract)
> -1 twg (for being a gross zombie with higher karma than many honest
> players.)
>
> nch (09 June 2020)
> +1 Falsifian (excellence in journalism)
> -1 Jason (to ensure eir ego doesn't grow too big up in the clouds above
> the rest
>   of us)
>
> grok (09 June 2020)
> +1 PSS (for noticing my mistake)
> -1 Cuddlebeam (for eir "joke")
>
> R. Lee (09 June 2020)
> +1 Cuddlebeam (for eir fun brand of distraction during a hard time)
> -1 Falsifian (frivolous CFJ)
>
> [New Week 08-June]
>
> Jason (07 June 2020)
> +1 Aris (Writing good proposals while having eir motivations questioned.)
> -1 Jason (Karma source, I've been up there a while)
>
> R. Lee (07 June 2020)
> +1 Tyler (seemingly engaged new player)
> -1 twg (in service of getting non active players below or at 0)
>
> G. (04 June 2020)
> +1 D. Margaux (for being a generally good person.)
> -1 Aris (for starting us down the road to criminalizing intent with that
> awful
>  forbidden arts thing, and continuing the criminalization of
> intent by
>  proposing penalties for the basic free act of voting.)
>
> Falsifian (04 June 2020)
> +1 nch (Great new office and first report!)
> -1 Falsifian (default karma source)
>
> [New Week 01-June]
>
> ATMunn (28 May 2020)
> +1 Agora (i have no clue what's going on so i don't know who else to pick)
> -1 ATMunn (pretending to come back and then disappearing again for 6
> months)
>
> nch (25 May 2020)
> +1 Aris (doing a hard job that I made harder)
> -1 nch (obliviousness)
>
> [New Week 25-May]
>
> Falsifian (24 May 2020)
> +1 Jason (doing the research)
> -1 Falsifian (I think I'll try being my own default karma source for a
> while
>   and see what happens)
>
> P.S.S. (24 May 2020)
> +1 Murphy (giving a timely and thorough response to my petition)
> -1 ATMunn (randomly selected karma source)
>
> Aris (18 May 2020)
> -1 Aris (being the 

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin via agora-discussion]

On 6/21/2020 12:49 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote:
> On 6/21/20 3:45 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote:
>> Herald's Weekly report
>>
>> Date of Last Report: 14 June 2020
>> Date of This Report: 21 June 2020
>>
>> Karma  Entity
>> -  --
>>
>> <= SHOGUN
>>
>> +6 Jason
>> +6 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
>> +5 Aris
>> +5 G.
>>
>> -  ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
>>
> I had to make a judgment call here because the rules aren't clear about
> ties for Shogun. I decided that no one would have it because the rules
> imply that it is unique, but if there are objections, I'll CFJ it.
> 

I think there's something on the cfj books somewhere that by default
"entity with highest/most X" is the empty set if there's a tie.  And in
paticular with that "(if any)" clause in the honor rule.  Don't remember
the cfj context, it wasn't honor, but that was my thinking when we were
drafting the rule (and how it's been marked by the previous heralds I think).

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Publius Scribonius Scholasticus via agora-discussion]

On 6/21/20 3:45 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote:
> Herald's Weekly report
> 
> Date of Last Report: 14 June 2020
> Date of This Report: 21 June 2020
> 
> Karma  Entity
> -  --
> 
> <= SHOGUN
> 
> +6 Jason
> +6 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
> +5 Aris
> +5 G.
> 
> -  ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
> 
I had to make a judgment call here because the rules aren't clear about
ties for Shogun. I decided that no one would have it because the rules
imply that it is unique, but if there are objections, I'll CFJ it.

-- 

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, Herald, Referee, Tailor, Pirate
Champion, Badge of the Great Agoran Revival, Badge of the Salted Earth

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Publius Scribonius Scholasticus via agora-discussion]

On Sun, May 17, 2020 at 6:53 PM Kerim Aydin via agora-discussion
 wrote:
>
>
> On 5/17/2020 3:28 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote:
> >
> > Karma  Entity
> > -  --
> >
> > +7 Jason
>
> Don't think this needs a CoE but you've lost the Shogun marker.
>

Thanks for catching that; I've re-added it for the next report.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin via agora-discussion]

On 5/17/2020 3:28 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus wrote:
> 
> Karma  Entity
> -  --
> 
> +7 Jason

Don't think this needs a CoE but you've lost the Shogun marker.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report: The Honour Roll

[Kerim Aydin via agora-discussion]

On 2/15/2020 9:28 AM, Alexis Hunt via agora-official wrote:
>
> =0 Falsifian
> =0 ATMunn
>

Minor note:  I tended to keep 0s on the list for the first report or two
after they became 0s (so it was clear that they had changed recently in
case anyone wanted to doubt the entries) then drop them.  Otherwise there
would be a lot more explicit 0s on the list.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Nch]

‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐
On Sunday, October 20, 2019 5:01 PM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:

> Herald's Weekly report
>
> Date of Last Report: 06 Oct 2019
> Date of This Report: 20 Oct 2019
>
> Karma Entity
>
> +6 Aris <= SHOGUN
> +5 G.
>
> - ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
>
> +3 Trigon
> +3 twg
> +1 Falsifian
> +1 Jason Cobb
> 00 Agora
> -1 omd
> -1 nch

Oh, honour is a person switch.

+1 nch because new starts should be fresh starts, right?
-1 Aris because no one Agoran should have all that power.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report (revised)

[Cuddle Beam]

Trigon having 3 Karma pleasantly scratches an itch I didn't even know I had.

On Mon, Feb 4, 2019 at 2:12 AM Kerim Aydin  wrote:

> Herald’s Weekly report
>
> Date of Last Report: 01 Feb 2018
> Date of This Report: 04 Feb 2019 (1st revision)
>
> KarmaEntity (np=not player)
>
><= SHOGUN
> -ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
> +3   Trigon
> +1   twg
> +1   D. Margaux
> +1   Corona
> +1   ATMunn
> +1   Aris
> +1   G.
>   0   Telnaior
>   0   Kenyon (np)
>   0   Ouri (np)
> -1   Tenhigitsune[1] (np)
> -1   CuddleBeam
> -1   Gaelan
> -1   V.J. Rada
> -1   Agora (np)
> -2   Jacob Arduino
> -2   Murphy
> -BELOW -4 LIE THE GAMMAS
><= HONOURLESS WORM
> -
> All other entities have 0 Karma (0's included on the list
> indicate an honour change since the last report).
> Notations of player/not-player and zombie status above are
> not complete switch reports, so are not self-ratifying.
> [1] aka 天火狐
>
>
> Notices of Honour:
>
> Telnaior (04 Feb 2019)
> +1 G. (for introducing a good competition at a thematic time to help
> patch flaws in the ruleset).
> -1 Jacob Arduino (for ceasing to exist in this time and place).
>
> [New Week 04-Feb]
>
> Gaelan (03 Feb 2019)
> +1 G (why the hell is G. negative?)
> -1 Tenhigitsune (e’s not active, e doesn’t need the karma)
>
> CuddleBeam (03 Feb 2019)
> +1 Trigon (for the cool RP)
> -1 Tenhigitsune (because zombies stink big poo poo)
>
> Telnaior (02 Feb 2019)
> +1 Agora (for being "positively ancient")
> -1 CuddleBeam (for making a ridiculous contract)
>
> Quarterly Karma Adjustment (G., 01 Feb 2019)
> +1 Kenyon
> +1 Ouri
> -2 Agora
>
> [Time of Last Report]
>
> Trigon (29 Jan 2019)
> +1 Telnaior for pointing out our Agoran Laziness.
> -1 D. Margaux for instigating the aforementioned.
>
> [New Week 28-Jan]
>
> G. (23 Jan 2019)
> -1 to twg for trying to force double-meanings onto "Quang"
> +1 to CuddleBeam for flooping the whoop.
>
> [New Week 21-Jan]
> [New Week 14-Jan]
> [New Week 07-Jan]
> [New Week 31-Dec]
> [New Week 24-Dec]
> [New Week 17-Dec]
>
> twg (14 Dec 2018)
> +1 G. (helping point out proposal errors)
> -1 twg (submitting proposals with errors)
>
> G. (14 Dec 2018)
> -1 Corona (random loss)
> +1 CuddleBeam (random gain)
>
> pokes, via G. (14 Dec 2018)
>   -1 twg (random loss)
>   +1 V.J. Rada (random gain)
>
> [New Week 10-Dec]
> [New Week 03-Dec]
>
> twg (02 Dec 2018)
> -1 Jacob (making the Assessor's life difficult by submitting complicated
>conditional votes and repeatedly changing them)
> +1 Ouri (being a non-player with non-zero karma)
>
> [New Week 26-Nov]
>
> twg (23 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (moneymaking use of Assessor's decision order discretion)
> +1 Trigon (eir proposal being mangled by aforementioned activities)
>
> D. Margaux (19 Nov 2018)
> +1 twg (spotting errors in Arbitor’s weekly)
> -1 D. Margaux (being careless with CFJ numbers)
>
> [New Week 19-Nov]
>
> Telnaior via Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 Gaelan (rebalancing)
>
> Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 V.J. Rada (rebalancing)
>
> G. (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 Murphy (rebalancing)
>
> [New Week 12-Nov]
>
> twg (11 Nov 2018)
> -1 G. (not having properly judged CFJ 3681 yet)
> +1 Sky Fox (being an obedient zombie)
>
> [New Week 05-Nov]
>
> ATMunn (04 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 VJ Rada (rebalancing)
>
> Trigon (01 Nov 2018)
> -1 G. for acting recklessly and not considering eir actions' effects
> +1 Gaelan because why is e at -3 when e hasn't even been here for months?
>
> G.  (31 Oct 2018)
> +1 twg (for reminding us about violet ribbons)
> -1 Trigon (for only awarding a violet ribbon to emself)
>
> [New Week 29-Oct]
>
> [New Week 22-Oct]
>
> D. Margaux (20 Oct 2018)
> twg +1 (Doomsday Clock was a very clever way to blow up the land minigame)
> Murphy -1 (impeding the due course of justice by leaving Arbitor stuff
> undone)
>
> [New Week 15-Oct]
>
> [New Week 08-Oct]
>
> D. Margaux (07 Oct 2018)
> +1 Aris for giving careful consideration to arguments
> -1 D Margaux for persisting in advocating perhaps a tenuous interpretation
> of the rules
>
> Gaelan via Master G. INVALID, NOT FIRST IN WEEK
> -1 twg   (for making someone a zombie who was clearly returning)
> +1 ATMunn (welcome back!
>
> twg (03 Oct 2018)
> +1 D. Margaux (managing to sneak this one past me)
> -1 Kenyon (arbitrarily selected zombie)
>
> Gaelan via Master G. (01 Oct 2018)
> +1 CuddleBeam (for taking the burden G.'s RL bank balance).
> -1 Ouri (more karma decay for zombies)
>
> D. Margaux (02 Oct 2018)
> +1 CuddleBeam for an ingenious pledge
> -1 D Margaux because eir karma is too high
>
> G. (01 Oct 2018)
> +1 twg (for this great addition to the assessor's results)
> -1 Ouri (zombies close to deregistration mean nonzero karma
> balance in Agora eventually).
>
> [New Week]
>
> twg (30 Sep 2018)
> +1 D. Margaux (fulfilling agreed obligation)
> -1 Telnaior (arbitrar

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

admitted - my search actually pinged that one but I was lazy
and didn't scroll (thought it was a false positive). correction
incoming.

On Sun, 25 Nov 2018, Reuben Staley wrote:
> CoE: this message is missing:
> 
> https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg33094.html
> 
> --
> Trigon
> 
> On Sun, Nov 25, 2018, 13:52 Kerim Aydin  
> >
> >
> > Herald’s Weekly report
> >
> > Date of Last Report: 16 Nov 2018
> > Date of This Report: 25 Nov 2018
> >
> > KarmaEntity (np=not player)
> > -
> > +5   twg   <= SHOGUN
> > -ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
> > +2   D. Margaux
> > +2   Corona
> > +1   Trigon
> > +1   ATMunn
> > +1   Aris
> > +1   Tenhigitsune[1] (zombie)
> > -1   Kenyon (np)
> > -1   Telnaior (zombie)
> > -1   Gaelan
> > -2   G.
> > -2   Ouri (np)
> > -2   CuddleBeam
> > -2   Murphy
> > -2   V.J. Rada
> > -BELOW -4 LIE THE GAMMAS
> > <= HONOURLESS WORM
> > -
> >
> > All other entities have 0 Karma (0's included on the list
> > indicate an honour change since the last report).
> > Notations of player/not-player and zombie status above are
> > not complete switch reports, so are not self-ratifying.
> > [1] aka 天火狐
> >
> > Notices of Honour:
> >
> > D. Margaux (19 Nov 2018)
> > +1 twg (spotting errors in Arbitor’s weekly)
> > -1 D. Margaux (being careless with CFJ numbers)
> >
> > [New Week 19-Nov]
> >
> > Telnaior via Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> > -1 twg (rebalancing)
> > +1 Gaelan (rebalancing)
> >
> > Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> > -1 twg (rebalancing)
> > +1 V.J. Rada (rebalancing)
> >
> > G. (16 Nov 2018)
> > -1 twg (rebalancing)
> > +1 Murphy (rebalancing)
> >
> > [Time of Last Report]
> > [New Week 12-Nov]
> >
> > twg (11 Nov 2018)
> > -1 G. (not having properly judged CFJ 3681 yet)
> > +1 Sky Fox (being an obedient zombie)
> >
> > [New Week 05-Nov]
> >
> > ATMunn (04 Nov 2018)
> > -1 twg (rebalancing)
> > +1 VJ Rada (rebalancing)
> >
> > Trigon (01 Nov 2018)
> > -1 G. for acting recklessly and not considering eir actions' effects
> > +1 Gaelan because why is e at -3 when e hasn't even been here for months?
> >
> > G.  (31 Oct 2018)
> > +1 twg (for reminding us about violet ribbons)
> > -1 Trigon (for only awarding a violet ribbon to emself)
> >
> > [New Week 29-Oct]
> >
> > [New Week 22-Oct]
> >
> > D. Margaux (20 Oct 2018)
> > twg +1 (Doomsday Clock was a very clever way to blow up the land minigame)
> > Murphy -1 (impeding the due course of justice by leaving Arbitor stuff
> > undone)
> >
> > [New Week 15-Oct]
> >
> > [New Week 08-Oct]
> >
> > D. Margaux (07 Oct 2018)
> > +1 Aris for giving careful consideration to arguments
> > -1 D Margaux for persisting in advocating perhaps a tenuous interpretation
> > of the rules
> >
> > Gaelan via Master G. INVALID, NOT FIRST IN WEEK
> > -1 twg   (for making someone a zombie who was clearly returning)
> > +1 ATMunn (welcome back!
> >
> > twg (03 Oct 2018)
> > +1 D. Margaux (managing to sneak this one past me)
> > -1 Kenyon (arbitrarily selected zombie)
> >
> > Gaelan via Master G. (01 Oct 2018)
> > +1 CuddleBeam (for taking the burden G.'s RL bank balance).
> > -1 Ouri (more karma decay for zombies)
> >
> > D. Margaux (02 Oct 2018)
> > +1 CuddleBeam for an ingenious pledge
> > -1 D Margaux because eir karma is too high
> >
> > G. (01 Oct 2018)
> > +1 twg (for this great addition to the assessor's results)
> > -1 Ouri (zombies close to deregistration mean nonzero karma
> >   balance in Agora eventually).
> >
> > [New Week]
> >
> > twg (30 Sep 2018)
> > +1 D. Margaux (fulfilling agreed obligation)
> > -1 Telnaior (arbitrarily selected zombie)
> >
> > Aris (24 Sep 2018)
> > -1 G. (unclear communication)
> > +1 omd (serving as our Distributor)
> >
> > Gaelan, via master G. (24 Sep 2018)
> > -1 Aris (because Gaelan may or may not feel like it).
> > +1 V.J. (or VJ) Rada, because eir name is confusing enough to be
> >   listed in two different ways within the Registrar's Report, and
> >   I like that.
> >
> > G. (24 Sep 2018)
> > -1 Aris (because really, I feel like it).
> > +1 CuddleBeam (because I'm tired of seeing that name at the bottom).
> >
> > [New Week]
> >
> > Trigon (23 Sep 2018)
> > -1 to D. Margaux for being a manipulator
> > +1 to D Margaux for helping debug zombie rules
> >
> > Aris (23 Sep 2018)
> > -1 G. (complaining about proposals being readded while resisting
> > any attempt to lower quorum or otherwise resolve the problem of
> > them failing quorum)
> > +1 D Margaux (helping fix problems by debugging the proposals)
> >
> > Telnaior, via master Aris (23 Sep 2018)
> > -1 D Margaux (manipulating zombies to gain honor)
> > +1 nichdel (being mainipulated)
> >
> > D. Margaux (23 Sep 2018)
> > -1 nichdel (having the misfortune of being D. Margaux’s zombie)
> > +1 D Margaux (for revealing what might be yet another zombie exploit)
> >
> > G. (23 Sep 2018)
> > -1 Aris (for persisting with group of low-quor

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Reuben Staley]

CoE: this message is missing:

https://www.mail-archive.com/agora-business@agoranomic.org/msg33094.html

--
Trigon

On Sun, Nov 25, 2018, 13:52 Kerim Aydin 
>
> Herald’s Weekly report
>
> Date of Last Report: 16 Nov 2018
> Date of This Report: 25 Nov 2018
>
> KarmaEntity (np=not player)
> -
> +5   twg   <= SHOGUN
> -ABOVE +4 STAND THE SAMURAI
> +2   D. Margaux
> +2   Corona
> +1   Trigon
> +1   ATMunn
> +1   Aris
> +1   Tenhigitsune[1] (zombie)
> -1   Kenyon (np)
> -1   Telnaior (zombie)
> -1   Gaelan
> -2   G.
> -2   Ouri (np)
> -2   CuddleBeam
> -2   Murphy
> -2   V.J. Rada
> -BELOW -4 LIE THE GAMMAS
> <= HONOURLESS WORM
> -
>
> All other entities have 0 Karma (0's included on the list
> indicate an honour change since the last report).
> Notations of player/not-player and zombie status above are
> not complete switch reports, so are not self-ratifying.
> [1] aka 天火狐
>
> Notices of Honour:
>
> D. Margaux (19 Nov 2018)
> +1 twg (spotting errors in Arbitor’s weekly)
> -1 D. Margaux (being careless with CFJ numbers)
>
> [New Week 19-Nov]
>
> Telnaior via Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 Gaelan (rebalancing)
>
> Aris (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 V.J. Rada (rebalancing)
>
> G. (16 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 Murphy (rebalancing)
>
> [Time of Last Report]
> [New Week 12-Nov]
>
> twg (11 Nov 2018)
> -1 G. (not having properly judged CFJ 3681 yet)
> +1 Sky Fox (being an obedient zombie)
>
> [New Week 05-Nov]
>
> ATMunn (04 Nov 2018)
> -1 twg (rebalancing)
> +1 VJ Rada (rebalancing)
>
> Trigon (01 Nov 2018)
> -1 G. for acting recklessly and not considering eir actions' effects
> +1 Gaelan because why is e at -3 when e hasn't even been here for months?
>
> G.  (31 Oct 2018)
> +1 twg (for reminding us about violet ribbons)
> -1 Trigon (for only awarding a violet ribbon to emself)
>
> [New Week 29-Oct]
>
> [New Week 22-Oct]
>
> D. Margaux (20 Oct 2018)
> twg +1 (Doomsday Clock was a very clever way to blow up the land minigame)
> Murphy -1 (impeding the due course of justice by leaving Arbitor stuff
> undone)
>
> [New Week 15-Oct]
>
> [New Week 08-Oct]
>
> D. Margaux (07 Oct 2018)
> +1 Aris for giving careful consideration to arguments
> -1 D Margaux for persisting in advocating perhaps a tenuous interpretation
> of the rules
>
> Gaelan via Master G. INVALID, NOT FIRST IN WEEK
> -1 twg   (for making someone a zombie who was clearly returning)
> +1 ATMunn (welcome back!
>
> twg (03 Oct 2018)
> +1 D. Margaux (managing to sneak this one past me)
> -1 Kenyon (arbitrarily selected zombie)
>
> Gaelan via Master G. (01 Oct 2018)
> +1 CuddleBeam (for taking the burden G.'s RL bank balance).
> -1 Ouri (more karma decay for zombies)
>
> D. Margaux (02 Oct 2018)
> +1 CuddleBeam for an ingenious pledge
> -1 D Margaux because eir karma is too high
>
> G. (01 Oct 2018)
> +1 twg (for this great addition to the assessor's results)
> -1 Ouri (zombies close to deregistration mean nonzero karma
>   balance in Agora eventually).
>
> [New Week]
>
> twg (30 Sep 2018)
> +1 D. Margaux (fulfilling agreed obligation)
> -1 Telnaior (arbitrarily selected zombie)
>
> Aris (24 Sep 2018)
> -1 G. (unclear communication)
> +1 omd (serving as our Distributor)
>
> Gaelan, via master G. (24 Sep 2018)
> -1 Aris (because Gaelan may or may not feel like it).
> +1 V.J. (or VJ) Rada, because eir name is confusing enough to be
>   listed in two different ways within the Registrar's Report, and
>   I like that.
>
> G. (24 Sep 2018)
> -1 Aris (because really, I feel like it).
> +1 CuddleBeam (because I'm tired of seeing that name at the bottom).
>
> [New Week]
>
> Trigon (23 Sep 2018)
> -1 to D. Margaux for being a manipulator
> +1 to D Margaux for helping debug zombie rules
>
> Aris (23 Sep 2018)
> -1 G. (complaining about proposals being readded while resisting
> any attempt to lower quorum or otherwise resolve the problem of
> them failing quorum)
> +1 D Margaux (helping fix problems by debugging the proposals)
>
> Telnaior, via master Aris (23 Sep 2018)
> -1 D Margaux (manipulating zombies to gain honor)
> +1 nichdel (being mainipulated)
>
> D. Margaux (23 Sep 2018)
> -1 nichdel (having the misfortune of being D. Margaux’s zombie)
> +1 D Margaux (for revealing what might be yet another zombie exploit)
>
> G. (23 Sep 2018)
> -1 Aris (for persisting with group of low-quorum proposals).
> +1 D. Margaux (for finding bugs after several votings).
>
> [New Week]
>
> D. Margaux (15 Sep 2018)
> -1 D. Margaux (misnaming G.)
> +1 G. (being gracious about that misnaming)
>
> [New Week]
>
> G. (9 Sep 2018)
> -1 Trigon (being generally MIA on land)
> +1 D. Margaux (keeping up officer report standards via SJ)
>
> [New Week]
>
> [New Week]
>
> G. 29 Aug 2018
> -1 G (not reading proposals carefully)
> +1 D. Margaux (reading carefully and researching back beyond eir tenure)
>
> twg 26 Aug 20

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

It's a fair cop, but in retrospect it cost me 60 Coins needlessly (over
my more visible bids) so there's some instant karma for me there too :P

On Mon, 9 Jul 2018, Timon Walshe-Grey wrote:

> Something something black kettle...
> 
> -twg
> 
> 
> ‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐
> 
> On July 9, 2018 7:45 PM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:
> 
> > ​​
> > 
> > Note there were some land bids placed at the end of this report.
> > 
> > On Mon, 9 Jul 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
> > 
> > > Herald’s Weekly report
> > > 
> > > [snip]
> > > 
> > > 
> > > ==
> > > 
> > > END OF HERALD'S WEEKLY REPORT
> > > 
> > > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +1)
> > > 
> > > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +2)
> > > 
> > > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (+6, -1)
> 
> 
>

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Timon Walshe-Grey]

Something something black kettle...

-twg


‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐

On July 9, 2018 7:45 PM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:

> ​​
> 
> Note there were some land bids placed at the end of this report.
> 
> On Mon, 9 Jul 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
> 
> > Herald’s Weekly report
> > 
> > [snip]
> > 
> > 
> > ==
> > 
> > END OF HERALD'S WEEKLY REPORT
> > 
> > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +1)
> > 
> > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +2)
> > 
> > I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (+6, -1)

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

Note there were some land bids placed at the end of this report.

On Mon, 9 Jul 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
> Herald’s Weekly report
> [snip]
> 
> END OF HERALD'S WEEKLY REPORT
> 
> I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +1)
> I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (-6, +2)
> I bid 66 Coins in the auction for the land unit at (+6, -1)

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Corona]

Thanks!

On 12/10/17, ATMunn  wrote:
> Congrats on your first report! You certainly did better than I did with my
> first report...
>
> Notice of Honour:
>   I lose 1 karma because I don't feel that it's fair for me to be shogun.
>   Corona gains one karma for a good first report.
>
> On 12/10/2017 11:47 AM, Corona wrote:
>> As Herald I publish the following weekly report:
>>
>> Court:
>>
>> KarmaEntity
>> -
>> SAMURAI
>> -
>> +4   ATMunn <-- SHOGUN
>> +3   o
>> +3   Alexis
>> +3   Telnaior
>> +3   G.
>> +2   Trigon
>> +2   Aris
>> +1   天火狐
>> -1   Quazie
>> -1   omd
>> -1   Bayushi
>> -2   ProofTechnique
>> -2   Murphy
>> -2   Ienpw III
>> -2   Gaelan
>> -4   CuddleBeam
>> -6   V.J. Rada <-- HONOURLESS WORM
>> -
>> GAMMAS
>> -
>> KarmaEntity
>>
>>
>> All other entities have 0 Karma.
>>
>> ---
>> Notices of Honour:
>>
>> Corona (28 Nov 2017)
>> -1 Corona (not giving karma to Alexis instead, intent to bribe)
>> +1 VJ Rada (has given Corona shinies, balancing eir karma)
>>
>> o (27 Nov 2017)
>> -1 o (spending too long at the top of the list)
>> +1 CuddleBeam (having been duly chastened)
>>
>> Alexis (27 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (generally poor sportsmanship)
>> +1 Telnaior (stepping up as Clork)
>>
>> PSS (27 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (disrespecting others, the game and sportsmanship)
>> +1 Aris (encouraging civility)
>>
>> G. (27 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (bad officing)
>> +1 ATMunn (being a good sport about ribbons)
>>
>> ATMunn (28 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (bad ADoP, bad officer, bad Agoran)
>> +1 G. (good long-term player who know's what e's doing)
>>
>> Telnaior (28 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (intentionally causing trouble several times)
>> +1 Corona (cool newbie)
>>
>> [New Week]
>>
>> PSS (20 Nov 2017)
>> -1 nichdel (for inactivity)
>> +1 ATMunn (for improving upon ADoP report)
>>
>> [New Week]
>>
>> ATMunn (16 Nov 2017)
>> -1 ATMunn (pushing boundaries of karma)
>> +1 G. (pushing boundaries of karma)
>>
>> V.J. Rada 15 Nov 2017)
>> -1 Quazie (for inactivity)
>> +1 Alexis (innovative timely rulekeepor)
>>
>> Telnaior (15 Nov 2017)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (being a contrarian)
>> +1 Alexis (Telnaior's favourite large proposal)
>>
>> [Last Report Wed Nov 15]
>> [New Week]
>>
>> G. (12 Nov 2017)
>> -1 天火狐 (for a low-effort newspaper report).
>> +1 omd (for quick response to Distributor directives).
>>
>> ATMunn (6 Nov 2017)
>> -1 ATMunn (for forgetting to state quorum on Decision initiations).
>> +1 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus (for putting up with such mistakes).
>>
>>
>> [New Week]
>>
>>
>> G. (3 Nov 17)
>> -1 Murphy (for being a near-Zombie).
>> +1 Alexis (for putting the time into this thesis).
>>
>> ATMunn (30 Oct 2017)
>> -1 omd (can't think of anyone else to lose karma and e is inactive).
>> +1 Trigon (for seeming to do really well so far at publishing rulesets).
>>
>> Alexis (30 Oct 2017)
>> -1 Alexis (for introducing such a silly pedantic bug into the ruleset).
>> +1 ATMunn (for putting up with it).
>>
>> Telnaior (30 Oct 2017)
>> -1 CuddleBeam (for attempting to game the karma system).
>> +1 Aris (for putting in a valiant effort as Promotor during busy period).
>>
>> V.J. Rada (30 Oct 2017)
>> -1 Bayushi (for inactivity).
>> +1 Alexis (for having to judge my stupid cfjs).
>>
>>
>> [New Week]
>>
>>
>> Telnaior (29 Oct 2017)
>> -1 ProofTechnique (for not existing but having more karma than other
>> inactives).
>> +1 天火狐 (for creating a very cool contract).
>>
>> o (27 Oct 17)
>> -1 CuddleBeam (for generally being contrarian)
>> +1 G. (for producing a magnificent judgement)
>>
>> Alexis (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 CuddleBeam (for objecting to deregistration making karma-sinks)
>> +1 nichdel (for jumping right back in)
>>
>> PSS (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 CuddleBeam (for confusing nichdel and being a contrarian)
>> +1 天火狐 (for being a fun player and pushing boundaries with language)
>>
>> Nichdel (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 PSS (for being a contrarian)
>> +1 o (for being the best at what e does)
>>
>> Trigon (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 Ienpw III (for being inactive)
>> +1 ATMunn (for being a fantastic active new player)
>>
>> ATMunn (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 Ienpw III (for being inactive)
>> +1 o (for being honest, hardworking and generally awesome player)
>>
>> Aris (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 ProofTechnique (for being inactive)
>> +1 Trigon (for being a new active player)
>>
>> V.J. Rada (25 Oct 17)
>> -1 omd (for being inactive)
>> +1 Telnaior (cool that V.J. Rada brought em back and being clever)
>>
>> G. (24 Oct 17)
>> -1 V.J. Rada (making a deputization mess)
>> +1 o (for being the one to clean up messes)
>>
>>
>> [New Week]
>>
>>
>> Telnaior (22 Oct 17)
>> -1 Gaelan (for slack Rulekeeping)
>> +1 Alexis (for being helpful)
>>
>> Alexis (22 Oct 17)
>> -1 CuddleBeam (for blocking deregistrations of inactives)
>> +1 Telnaior (for coming back with vigour)
>>
>> V.J. Rada (22 Oct 17)
>> -1 Murphy (being inactive)
>> +1 ATMunn (f

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[ATMunn]

Congrats on your first report! You certainly did better than I did with my 
first report...

Notice of Honour:
I lose 1 karma because I don't feel that it's fair for me to be shogun.
Corona gains one karma for a good first report.

On 12/10/2017 11:47 AM, Corona wrote:

As Herald I publish the following weekly report:

Court:

KarmaEntity
-
SAMURAI
-
+4   ATMunn <-- SHOGUN
+3   o
+3   Alexis
+3   Telnaior
+3   G.
+2   Trigon
+2   Aris
+1   天火狐
-1   Quazie
-1   omd
-1   Bayushi
-2   ProofTechnique
-2   Murphy
-2   Ienpw III
-2   Gaelan
-4   CuddleBeam
-6   V.J. Rada <-- HONOURLESS WORM
-
GAMMAS
-
KarmaEntity


All other entities have 0 Karma.

---
Notices of Honour:

Corona (28 Nov 2017)
-1 Corona (not giving karma to Alexis instead, intent to bribe)
+1 VJ Rada (has given Corona shinies, balancing eir karma)

o (27 Nov 2017)
-1 o (spending too long at the top of the list)
+1 CuddleBeam (having been duly chastened)

Alexis (27 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (generally poor sportsmanship)
+1 Telnaior (stepping up as Clork)

PSS (27 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (disrespecting others, the game and sportsmanship)
+1 Aris (encouraging civility)

G. (27 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (bad officing)
+1 ATMunn (being a good sport about ribbons)

ATMunn (28 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (bad ADoP, bad officer, bad Agoran)
+1 G. (good long-term player who know's what e's doing)

Telnaior (28 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (intentionally causing trouble several times)
+1 Corona (cool newbie)

[New Week]

PSS (20 Nov 2017)
-1 nichdel (for inactivity)
+1 ATMunn (for improving upon ADoP report)

[New Week]

ATMunn (16 Nov 2017)
-1 ATMunn (pushing boundaries of karma)
+1 G. (pushing boundaries of karma)

V.J. Rada 15 Nov 2017)
-1 Quazie (for inactivity)
+1 Alexis (innovative timely rulekeepor)

Telnaior (15 Nov 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (being a contrarian)
+1 Alexis (Telnaior's favourite large proposal)

[Last Report Wed Nov 15]
[New Week]

G. (12 Nov 2017)
-1 天火狐 (for a low-effort newspaper report).
+1 omd (for quick response to Distributor directives).

ATMunn (6 Nov 2017)
-1 ATMunn (for forgetting to state quorum on Decision initiations).
+1 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus (for putting up with such mistakes).


[New Week]


G. (3 Nov 17)
-1 Murphy (for being a near-Zombie).
+1 Alexis (for putting the time into this thesis).

ATMunn (30 Oct 2017)
-1 omd (can't think of anyone else to lose karma and e is inactive).
+1 Trigon (for seeming to do really well so far at publishing rulesets).

Alexis (30 Oct 2017)
-1 Alexis (for introducing such a silly pedantic bug into the ruleset).
+1 ATMunn (for putting up with it).

Telnaior (30 Oct 2017)
-1 CuddleBeam (for attempting to game the karma system).
+1 Aris (for putting in a valiant effort as Promotor during busy period).

V.J. Rada (30 Oct 2017)
-1 Bayushi (for inactivity).
+1 Alexis (for having to judge my stupid cfjs).


[New Week]


Telnaior (29 Oct 2017)
-1 ProofTechnique (for not existing but having more karma than other
inactives).
+1 天火狐 (for creating a very cool contract).

o (27 Oct 17)
-1 CuddleBeam (for generally being contrarian)
+1 G. (for producing a magnificent judgement)

Alexis (25 Oct 17)
-1 CuddleBeam (for objecting to deregistration making karma-sinks)
+1 nichdel (for jumping right back in)

PSS (25 Oct 17)
-1 CuddleBeam (for confusing nichdel and being a contrarian)
+1 天火狐 (for being a fun player and pushing boundaries with language)

Nichdel (25 Oct 17)
-1 PSS (for being a contrarian)
+1 o (for being the best at what e does)

Trigon (25 Oct 17)
-1 Ienpw III (for being inactive)
+1 ATMunn (for being a fantastic active new player)

ATMunn (25 Oct 17)
-1 Ienpw III (for being inactive)
+1 o (for being honest, hardworking and generally awesome player)

Aris (25 Oct 17)
-1 ProofTechnique (for being inactive)
+1 Trigon (for being a new active player)

V.J. Rada (25 Oct 17)
-1 omd (for being inactive)
+1 Telnaior (cool that V.J. Rada brought em back and being clever)

G. (24 Oct 17)
-1 V.J. Rada (making a deputization mess)
+1 o (for being the one to clean up messes)


[New Week]


Telnaior (22 Oct 17)
-1 Gaelan (for slack Rulekeeping)
+1 Alexis (for being helpful)

Alexis (22 Oct 17)
-1 CuddleBeam (for blocking deregistrations of inactives)
+1 Telnaior (for coming back with vigour)

V.J. Rada (22 Oct 17)
-1 Murphy (being inactive)
+1 ATMunn (for being a good player, and proposals)

G. (22 Oct 2017)
-1 V.J. Rada (random choice), +1 ATMunn (good first proposal).


~Corona

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Geoffrey Spear]

On Mon, Dec 6, 2010 at 9:57 AM, Geoffrey Spear  wrote:
>    6 5R     ehird               3   Puisine Justice  Backup Justiciar

Note: the spelling of Puisne is corrected in the draft; I'm not CoEing
myself because it's probably a synonym and not self-ratifying anyway.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

On Mon, 22 Nov 2010, Geoffrey Spear wrote:
> Herald's Weekly Report

ps. missing leadership tokens.

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Ed Murphy]

G. wrote:

> On Fri, 12 Nov 2010, Geoffrey Spear wrote:
>> On Fri, Nov 12, 2010 at 10:26 AM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:
>>> It would also promote the first rebel (omd) such that Yally would
>>> have promoted emself to Grand Vizier for a cost of 5 ergs, and eir
>>> rubbberstamps/vetos would have failed.  rgh.  -G.
>>
>> I don't feel *too* sorry for the Assessor, considering e hasn't
>> assigned the relevant CFJs.
> 
> Heh.  must resist temptation to reassign case to the justiciar given
> the situation.  -G.

I got dragged off to a campout for the weekend.  Have just caught up
on Agora mail, will start catching up on official duties shortly.

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

On Fri, 12 Nov 2010, Geoffrey Spear wrote:
> On Fri, Nov 12, 2010 at 10:26 AM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:
> > It would also promote the first rebel (omd) such that Yally would
> > have promoted emself to Grand Vizier for a cost of 5 ergs, and eir
> > rubbberstamps/vetos would have failed.  rgh.  -G.
> 
> I don't feel *too* sorry for the Assessor, considering e hasn't
> assigned the relevant CFJs.

Heh.  must resist temptation to reassign case to the justiciar given
the situation.  -G.

Re: DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Geoffrey Spear]

On Fri, Nov 12, 2010 at 10:26 AM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:
> It would also promote the first rebel (omd) such that Yally would
> have promoted emself to Grand Vizier for a cost of 5 ergs, and eir
> rubbberstamps/vetos would have failed.  rgh.  -G.

I don't feel *too* sorry for the Assessor, considering e hasn't
assigned the relevant CFJs.

DIS: Re: OFF: [Herald] Weekly Report

[Kerim Aydin]

On Fri, 12 Nov 2010, Geoffrey Spear wrote: 
> DISCLAIMER: The below is based on the interpretation that ehird was
> not a Rebel; a CFJ is pending.  If it is determined that e was a
> Rebel, ehird was the 5th Rebel, Wooble was the 6th Rebel, and the
> Rebellion succeeded, reordering the List.

It would also promote the first rebel (omd) such that Yally would
have promoted emself to Grand Vizier for a cost of 5 ergs, and eir 
rubbberstamps/vetos would have failed.  rgh.  -G.