DIS: Re: OFF: Re: [Herald] The Scroll of Agora
On Mon, 22 Apr 2019, Kerim Aydin wrote: I intend to ratify the below Herald's list of Patent Titles and holders as being correct as of its publication date of 31-Mar-2019, Without Objection. [This would not ratify the informal categories of championship]. Are you sure? Greetings, Ørjan.
Re: DIS: Re: OFF: Re: [Herald] The Scroll of Agora
Normally I'd agree with Gaelan, but I think the dependent action motivation is fairly compelling. -Aris On Mon, Apr 22, 2019 at 10:26 AM Kerim Aydin wrote: > > > I don't mind either way honestly, but last ratification was circa-2014 IIRC, > so we can't go back past whenever that date was. > > Motivation was because of the recent dependent action fix and the fact that > patent titles are often awarded by dependent actions, so it's kind of to > close out that chapter of uncertainty. > > On 4/22/2019 10:07 AM, Gaelan Steele wrote: > > I kinda feel like patent titles should be one of those things that > > shouldn’t be ratified—we should be able to recognize titles that were > > accidentally omitted at some point. I don’t feel quite strongly enough to > > object, but I Grumble Loudly. > > > > Gaelan > > > >> On Apr 22, 2019, at 9:30 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: > >> > >> > >> I intend to ratify the below Herald's list of Patent Titles and holders as > >> being correct as of its publication date of 31-Mar-2019, Without Objection. > >> [This would not ratify the informal categories of championship]. > >> > >> > >>> On 3/31/2019 8:40 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: > >>> = > >>>THE SCROLL OF AGORA > >>> === > >>> Herald's Monthly Report > >>> March 31, 2018 > >>>--- > >>> RECENT CHANGES > >>>--- > >>>27 Feb 10 D. Margaux awarded Champion (x2) by Politics > >>>04 Mar 19 Gaelan awarded the Patent Title Too Intense > >>>04 Mar 19 Telnaior awared the Patent Title Tiger Team > >>>15 Mar 19 twg awarded the Patent Title Helping Hand > >>>--- > >>>CHAMPION by > >>>--- > >>> Anarchy Alexis > >>>Apathy ais523. Aris, Murphy, o, Sprocklem, The Sky Fox > >>>Zachary Watterson, Quazie, > >>>Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, tmanthe2nd > >>>Gaelan, Ienpw III, Veggiekeks, omd, > >>>V.J. Rada, Bayushi. nichdel, grok, babelian > >>> Cards Taral, G., Murphy, OscarMeyr, root > >>> Clout ais523, Alexis > >>> Election G. > >>>Escape omd > >>>High Score Elysion, G., Levi, Murphy(x2), Steve, > >>>ais523(x3), Pavitra, omd(x4), Alexis(x2), > >>>root, Wooble, Tiger, Murphy, BobTHJ, Walker > >>> Junta ais523(x2), the AFO, omd(x2), G., OscarMeyr, > >>>Alexis, nichdel > >>>Leadership ais523 > >>> Lotto Alexis, omd > >>>Maniac Craig, root > >>> Musicianship Zefram, ais523, Wooble, omd, Tiger > >>> Paradox G., Murphy, root, BobTHJ (x2), ais523, ehird, > >>>Alexis, Bucky(x2), omd > >>> Politics Aris, D. Margaux (x2) > >>> Proposal Human Point Two, Morendil, Steve(x3), > >>>Andre(x3), ais523(x4), Canada, Bucky, G.(x2), > >>>omd(x2), woggle, Spitemaster, allispaul, Yally, > >>>BobTHJ, Murphy, Tiger, Alexis(x3), Andon, twg, > >>>CuddleBeam, Trigon, D. Margaux(x501) > >>> Renaissance ais523, Alexis(x3), Murphy, G.(x2) > >>> Solitude ais523(x2), Alexis(x2), omd > >>>Tournament Wooble, root, Taral, OscarMeyr, Aris > >>>Publius Scribonius Scholasticus > >>> Via Ratification The President > >>> Unspecified Blob, elJefe, General Chaos, Steve, > >>>Chuck, Dave Bowen, favor, Garth, Ian, > >>>Jeffrey, KoJen, Michael, Oerjan, Swann, t, > >>>Timothy, Troublemaker at Large, Vanyel(x2), > >>>Wes(x2). *(7/6): Chuck, elJefe, Kelly, KoJen, > >>>Morendil, Steve, Swann, Troublemaker at > >>>Large; *(4/3): Chuck, Kelly, KoJen, Steve, > >>>Troublemaker at Large, Wes; *(3/2): Chuck, > >>>Kelly, Steve; *(5/3): Kelly, Steve; *(11/6): > >>>Kelly > >>>*(N/P): Full patent title is Champion*(N/P) > >>>where N/P is the winning ratio. > >>> > >>> ORDER OF THE HERO OF AGORA NOMIC > >>> > >>> GRAND HERO OF AGORA NOMIC > >>>
Re: DIS: Re: OFF: Re: [Herald] The Scroll of Agora
I don't mind either way honestly, but last ratification was circa-2014 IIRC, so we can't go back past whenever that date was. Motivation was because of the recent dependent action fix and the fact that patent titles are often awarded by dependent actions, so it's kind of to close out that chapter of uncertainty. On 4/22/2019 10:07 AM, Gaelan Steele wrote: I kinda feel like patent titles should be one of those things that shouldn’t be ratified—we should be able to recognize titles that were accidentally omitted at some point. I don’t feel quite strongly enough to object, but I Grumble Loudly. Gaelan On Apr 22, 2019, at 9:30 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: I intend to ratify the below Herald's list of Patent Titles and holders as being correct as of its publication date of 31-Mar-2019, Without Objection. [This would not ratify the informal categories of championship]. On 3/31/2019 8:40 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: = THE SCROLL OF AGORA === Herald's Monthly Report March 31, 2018 --- RECENT CHANGES --- 27 Feb 10 D. Margaux awarded Champion (x2) by Politics 04 Mar 19 Gaelan awarded the Patent Title Too Intense 04 Mar 19 Telnaior awared the Patent Title Tiger Team 15 Mar 19 twg awarded the Patent Title Helping Hand --- CHAMPION by --- Anarchy Alexis Apathy ais523. Aris, Murphy, o, Sprocklem, The Sky Fox Zachary Watterson, Quazie, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, tmanthe2nd Gaelan, Ienpw III, Veggiekeks, omd, V.J. Rada, Bayushi. nichdel, grok, babelian Cards Taral, G., Murphy, OscarMeyr, root Clout ais523, Alexis Election G. Escape omd High Score Elysion, G., Levi, Murphy(x2), Steve, ais523(x3), Pavitra, omd(x4), Alexis(x2), root, Wooble, Tiger, Murphy, BobTHJ, Walker Junta ais523(x2), the AFO, omd(x2), G., OscarMeyr, Alexis, nichdel Leadership ais523 Lotto Alexis, omd Maniac Craig, root Musicianship Zefram, ais523, Wooble, omd, Tiger Paradox G., Murphy, root, BobTHJ (x2), ais523, ehird, Alexis, Bucky(x2), omd Politics Aris, D. Margaux (x2) Proposal Human Point Two, Morendil, Steve(x3), Andre(x3), ais523(x4), Canada, Bucky, G.(x2), omd(x2), woggle, Spitemaster, allispaul, Yally, BobTHJ, Murphy, Tiger, Alexis(x3), Andon, twg, CuddleBeam, Trigon, D. Margaux(x501) Renaissance ais523, Alexis(x3), Murphy, G.(x2) Solitude ais523(x2), Alexis(x2), omd Tournament Wooble, root, Taral, OscarMeyr, Aris Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Via Ratification The President Unspecified Blob, elJefe, General Chaos, Steve, Chuck, Dave Bowen, favor, Garth, Ian, Jeffrey, KoJen, Michael, Oerjan, Swann, t, Timothy, Troublemaker at Large, Vanyel(x2), Wes(x2). *(7/6): Chuck, elJefe, Kelly, KoJen, Morendil, Steve, Swann, Troublemaker at Large; *(4/3): Chuck, Kelly, KoJen, Steve, Troublemaker at Large, Wes; *(3/2): Chuck, Kelly, Steve; *(5/3): Kelly, Steve; *(11/6): Kelly *(N/P): Full patent title is Champion*(N/P) where N/P is the winning ratio. ORDER OF THE HERO OF AGORA NOMIC GRAND HERO OF AGORA NOMIC Peter Suber, Chuck Carroll, Douglas Hofstadter, Michael Norrish HERO OF AGORA NOMIC Murphy, G. HIGHER EDUCATION Associate of Nomic (A.N.): G., Alexis Bachelor of Nomic (B.N.):elJefe, favor, Steve, Vanyel, Kolja A., Murphy,
DIS: Re: OFF: Re: [Herald] The Scroll of Agora
I kinda feel like patent titles should be one of those things that shouldn’t be ratified—we should be able to recognize titles that were accidentally omitted at some point. I don’t feel quite strongly enough to object, but I Grumble Loudly. Gaelan > On Apr 22, 2019, at 9:30 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: > > > I intend to ratify the below Herald's list of Patent Titles and holders as > being correct as of its publication date of 31-Mar-2019, Without Objection. > [This would not ratify the informal categories of championship]. > > >> On 3/31/2019 8:40 AM, Kerim Aydin wrote: >>= >> THE SCROLL OF AGORA >> === >> Herald's Monthly Report >> March 31, 2018 >> --- >> RECENT CHANGES >> --- >> 27 Feb 10 D. Margaux awarded Champion (x2) by Politics >> 04 Mar 19 Gaelan awarded the Patent Title Too Intense >> 04 Mar 19 Telnaior awared the Patent Title Tiger Team >> 15 Mar 19 twg awarded the Patent Title Helping Hand >> --- >> CHAMPION by >> --- >> Anarchy Alexis >> Apathy ais523. Aris, Murphy, o, Sprocklem, The Sky Fox >> Zachary Watterson, Quazie, >> Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, tmanthe2nd >> Gaelan, Ienpw III, Veggiekeks, omd, >> V.J. Rada, Bayushi. nichdel, grok, babelian >>Cards Taral, G., Murphy, OscarMeyr, root >>Clout ais523, Alexis >> Election G. >> Escape omd >> High Score Elysion, G., Levi, Murphy(x2), Steve, >> ais523(x3), Pavitra, omd(x4), Alexis(x2), >> root, Wooble, Tiger, Murphy, BobTHJ, Walker >>Junta ais523(x2), the AFO, omd(x2), G., OscarMeyr, >> Alexis, nichdel >> Leadership ais523 >>Lotto Alexis, omd >> Maniac Craig, root >> Musicianship Zefram, ais523, Wooble, omd, Tiger >> Paradox G., Murphy, root, BobTHJ (x2), ais523, ehird, >> Alexis, Bucky(x2), omd >> Politics Aris, D. Margaux (x2) >> Proposal Human Point Two, Morendil, Steve(x3), >> Andre(x3), ais523(x4), Canada, Bucky, G.(x2), >> omd(x2), woggle, Spitemaster, allispaul, Yally, >> BobTHJ, Murphy, Tiger, Alexis(x3), Andon, twg, >> CuddleBeam, Trigon, D. Margaux(x501) >> Renaissance ais523, Alexis(x3), Murphy, G.(x2) >> Solitude ais523(x2), Alexis(x2), omd >> Tournament Wooble, root, Taral, OscarMeyr, Aris >> Publius Scribonius Scholasticus >> Via Ratification The President >> Unspecified Blob, elJefe, General Chaos, Steve, >> Chuck, Dave Bowen, favor, Garth, Ian, >> Jeffrey, KoJen, Michael, Oerjan, Swann, t, >> Timothy, Troublemaker at Large, Vanyel(x2), >> Wes(x2). *(7/6): Chuck, elJefe, Kelly, KoJen, >> Morendil, Steve, Swann, Troublemaker at >> Large; *(4/3): Chuck, Kelly, KoJen, Steve, >> Troublemaker at Large, Wes; *(3/2): Chuck, >> Kelly, Steve; *(5/3): Kelly, Steve; *(11/6): >> Kelly >> *(N/P): Full patent title is Champion*(N/P) >> where N/P is the winning ratio. >> >> ORDER OF THE HERO OF AGORA NOMIC >> >> GRAND HERO OF AGORA NOMIC >> Peter Suber, Chuck Carroll, Douglas Hofstadter, >> Michael Norrish >> HERO OF AGORA NOMIC >> Murphy, G. >> >> HIGHER EDUCATION >> >> Associate of Nomic (A.N.): G., Alexis >> Bachelor of Nomic (B.N.):elJefe, favor, >> Steve, Vanyel, >> Kolja A., Murphy, >> Alexis >> Master of Nomic: ais523 >> Doctor of Nomic History (D.N.Hist.): Swann, Vlad >> Doctor of Nomic Philosophy (D.N.Phil.): S
