Re: [akka-user] Configuration Compatibility Check ignored when using Cluster(system).join(address)

2018-02-25 Thread Patrik Nordwall
The config check fits better with the joinSeedNodes process. It’s done before the actual joining is done. I’d recommend to always use joinSeedNodes rather than join, also for manual joining. It can be a list with one entry. We should probably change Akka management to use joinSeedNodes instead of

Re: [akka-user] Configuration Compatibility Check ignored when using Cluster(system).join(address)

2018-02-24 Thread frederic arno
Thank you Patrick, I see this behavior is expected. Considering joining a cluster manually, what is the difference between the joinSeedNodes and the join processes? What makes the join process so different that nodes' configurations do not need to be checked for compatibility? Thanks, Fred On

Re: [akka-user] Configuration Compatibility Check ignored when using Cluster(system).join(address)

2018-02-24 Thread Patrik Nordwall
It’s only part of the joinSeedNodes process. Perhaps that is missing in docs, and contribution fixing that is welcome. /Patrik lör 24 feb. 2018 kl. 18:13 skrev Frederic : > Hello all, > > I've just done a few tests with the new Configuration Compatibility Check > and

[akka-user] Configuration Compatibility Check ignored when using Cluster(system).join(address)

2018-02-24 Thread Frederic
Hello all, I've just done a few tests with the new Configuration Compatibility Check and noticed that no compatibility check is performed (aka checks are ignored) when joining the cluster manually using Cluster(system).join(address). Is that expected? I didn't find any documentation