Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-19 Thread Gene Heskett
On Saturday 19 August 2006 03:30, Geert Uytterhoeven wrote: >On Fri, 18 Aug 2006, Gene Heskett wrote: >> On Friday 18 August 2006 11:35, Toomas Aas wrote: >> >I'm planning to upgrade my Amanda server (currently 2.4.5) to 2.5.0p2. >> >I'm wondering whether GNU tar 1.13.25 is still "officially" consi

Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-19 Thread Geert Uytterhoeven
On Fri, 18 Aug 2006, Gene Heskett wrote: > On Friday 18 August 2006 11:35, Toomas Aas wrote: > >I'm planning to upgrade my Amanda server (currently 2.4.5) to 2.5.0p2. > >I'm wondering whether GNU tar 1.13.25 is still "officially" considered a > >good version, or is it absolutely required to upgrade

Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-18 Thread Gene Heskett
On Friday 18 August 2006 12:01, Ian Turner wrote: >Toomas, > >GNU tar 1.13 should be good; No Ian, plain 1.13 is broken, 1.13-19, 1.13-25, and 1.15-1 are the known good versions. >The real troublemaker is tar 1.14, which > will silently corrupt your archives and throw away data. Unfortunately,

Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-18 Thread Gene Heskett
On Friday 18 August 2006 11:35, Toomas Aas wrote: >Hello! > >I'm planning to upgrade my Amanda server (currently 2.4.5) to 2.5.0p2. >I'm wondering whether GNU tar 1.13.25 is still "officially" considered a >good version, or is it absolutely required to upgrade to 1.15.1? > >I noticed that when inst

Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-18 Thread Toomas Aas
Ian Turner wrote: On Friday 18 August 2006 11:35, Toomas Aas wrote: BTW, I currently use dump for backups, so gtar is only used for indexes. No, Amanda will even use dump to generate indices. So actually you don't need tar at all. Of course, what was I thinking.

Re: Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-18 Thread Ian Turner
Toomas, GNU tar 1.13 should be good; The real troublemaker is tar 1.14, which will silently corrupt your archives and throw away data. Unfortunately, some distributions patch their tar with other code, so some versions of tar 1.13 are problematic, whereas some versions of tar 1.14 are perfectly

Is GNU tar 1.13.25 still good with 2.5.0p2?

2006-08-18 Thread Toomas Aas
Hello! I'm planning to upgrade my Amanda server (currently 2.4.5) to 2.5.0p2. I'm wondering whether GNU tar 1.13.25 is still "officially" considered a good version, or is it absolutely required to upgrade to 1.15.1? I noticed that when installing Amanda from FreeBSD ports, the installation p