Michael, I like this. I have a few comments on some of your open questions:
> Discovery: > mDNS or GRASP? I feel very strongly that we need the ANI to be as self-contained as possible. Therefore, it must be possible for the ANI to create itself without depending on mDNS. Therefore, we must use GRASP discovery (or flooding, if we prefer an announcement method) for AN nodes. > one discovery method for BRSKI and ACP, or several? Non-ANI nodes can also use BRSKI. So to say this one more time, since I won't be in Seoul: BRSKI proxies MUST be discoverable by both mDNS and GRASP. (One open question in my mind is this: does the pledge know or care whether it is dealing with a proxy or directly with the registrar, if the registrar happens to be on the local link? That does affect some details, at least in the GRASP case.) > multicast domain info? > packet formats For the discovery methods, that is already settled by mDNS and GRASP, isn't it? For BRSKI itself and ACP formation, the formats belong in the BRSKI and ACP drafts. Regards Brian On 11/11/2016 05:04, Michael Behringer (mbehring) wrote: > I had already sent out an early version of the state machines before, here an > update. > > To the high level state machine, I added a state "Proxy mode". A node is in > that state when the ACP is up AND it can see a registrar. Other than that, I > think the high level diagram should be ok. Looking for feedback. > > The state machine for the BRSKI pledge (it's a detail on the ANIMA state > machine) still has a lot of open questions. Most are under discussion. I > tried to illustrate where we have open points. > > I now tried also a state machine for the ACP. I'd appreciate some feedback on > it. > > To me, the big open things are: > - nail down discovery protocol and packet formats for both discoveries (for > bootstrap and ACP). > - decide which (if any) feedback we want to give to the pledge. > > But, I think these diagrams show nicely how all the drafts fit together, > which was the purpose of this exercise. > > Feedback? See you in Seoul! (Will be there from Sunday evening) > Michael > > > > > _______________________________________________ > Anima mailing list > Anima@ietf.org > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/anima > _______________________________________________ Anima mailing list Anima@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/anima
