Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

On Tue, Jan 30, 2018 at 6:25 AM, Dilan Udara Ariyaratne wrote: > Hi Imesh, > > +1 to this suggestion. > > My personal experience is that even our users find it confusing to see > dockerfile definitions for a product or product profile in multiple > repositories. > Thus, it

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

On Mon, Jan 29, 2018 at 7:36 AM, Imesh Gunaratne wrote: > On Mon, Jan 29, 2018 at 6:58 AM, Muhammed Shariq wrote: > >> Hi Imesh / all, >> >> Personally, I think the best option going forward is to maintain a single >> set of docker image across all platforms.

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

Hi Imesh, +1 to this suggestion. My personal experience is that even our users find it confusing to see dockerfile definitions for a product or product profile in multiple repositories. Thus, it would be quite intuitive to have a single source of truth per each product or product profile in the

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

On Mon, Jan 29, 2018 at 6:58 AM, Muhammed Shariq wrote: > Hi Imesh / all, > > Personally, I think the best option going forward is to maintain a single > set of docker image across all platforms. It's true that there is a concern > of users having to do more work, but in

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

On Mon, Jan 22, 2018 at 2:46 PM, Pubudu Gunatilaka wrote: > Hi Imesh, > > It is very convenient if we can reuse the docker image. AFAIU if we follow > the above approach we can use a single docker image in all the container > platforms. > > One of the drawbacks I see with this

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

In API Manager K8s artifacts, what we have followed is not having an image-per-profile method. With the introduction of Config Maps, it has become only two base images - for APIM and Analytics. Its extremely helpful from the maintenance PoV that we have a single set of Dockerfiles, but has a

Re: [Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

Hi Imesh, It is very convenient if we can reuse the docker image. AFAIU if we follow the above approach we can use a single docker image in all the container platforms. One of the drawbacks I see with this approach is that the user has to update the volume mounts with the necessary jar files,

[Architecture] Proposal to Use a Single Set of WSO2 Docker Images for All Container Platforms

Hi All, Currently, we build Docker images for each platform (Docker, Kubernetes, DC/OS, etc) for each WSO2 product profile (EI: Integrator, MB, BPS; API-M: Gateway, Key Manager, Pub/Store, etc). AFAIU, the main reason to do this was bundling platform specific JAR files (membership scheme JAR file