Re: should Archiva talk about requesting to become a top level project?

2008-02-25 Thread Arnaud HERITIER
+1 Arnaud On Sat, Feb 23, 2008 at 7:27 PM, Joakim Erdfelt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Here's my +1 Initially I was a little skeptical that we could pull off a TLP, I had this feeling that we hadn't yet reached the level of interest and participation that Continuum has, but since this email

Re: Recent contributions

2008-02-25 Thread Maria Odea Ching
Hi Dario, I've already applied MRM-687 and MRM-692. I still need to take a further look at the rest. Anyway, could you also provide tests for MRM-687 and MRM-206? :-) Thanks again! -Deng On Fri, Feb 15, 2008 at 12:06 AM, Dário Oliveros [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi there, I've recently

Re: [discuss] Archiva TLP proposal

2008-02-25 Thread Edwin Punzalan
I'd surely love to see archiva make the TLP... which I think it deserves. I'm not good with words when it comes to things like charters... so I'll leave that to the experts. Also, I see great things happening to Archiva with Deng as chair so I do not have any better nominees in mind. ^_^ On

from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
Hello, I've repackaged and improved the spring support for plexus components in a dedicated poject -- https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/maven/archiva/branches/springy/plexus-spring/ This new module provides runtime translation from plexus component descriptors to a Spring XML context, using a

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
Can someone confirm the plexus behavior for IoC : When the target field is a Map or a Collection and no role-hint is specified, inject all component implementations When the target field is the component interface and no role-hint is specified, inject the no-hint component or the one with

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread Brett Porter
On 25/02/2008, at 10:23 PM, nicolas de loof wrote: Can someone confirm the plexus behavior for IoC : When the target field is a Map or a Collection and no role-hint is specified, inject all component implementations When the target field is the component interface and no role-hint is

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
On plexus XML descriptors, the field-name seems to be optional... ( CacheFailuresTransferTest.xml) This makes things more complex on the spring side. Is this a common use case or can we live without this feature ? I've found the bug in archiva-proxy CacheFailuresTransferTest : there was some

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread Brett Porter
On 26/02/2008, at 1:46 AM, nicolas de loof wrote: On plexus XML descriptors, the field-name seems to be optional... ( CacheFailuresTransferTest.xml) Yes, I think it will attempt to guess based on the interface type if there is only one. This makes things more complex on the spring

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
This makes things more complex on the spring side. Is this a common use case or can we live without this feature ? If that's not doable, can we throw an unsupported exception if it's not given? An ApplicationContextException is thrown in such case on current codebase. I will

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
archiva-proxy CacheFailuresTransferTest and archiva-policies CachedFailuresPolicyTest no pass running under spring applicationContext. I've added a minimal Contextualizable support for components that do lookup in the plexusContainer. Some more work required to build full archiva with spring ;-)

[OT] Re: An experiment with Spring... What about OSGi ?

2008-02-25 Thread Ludovic Maitre
Hi Brett, all, Have you considered using OSGi instead of [Plexus|Spring] ? I'm not an expert of one or the other, but i try to do some projects with OSGi since a few months and i like it. Best regards, Brett Porter a écrit : Hi, Given the discussion yesterday, I played around with some

Re: [OT] Re: An experiment with Spring... What about OSGi ?

2008-02-25 Thread Ludovic Maitre
Hi Carlos, Thanks for your answer, Carlos Sanchez a écrit : spring has good integration with OSGi to enable Spring beans to be OSGi services. Yes, i'm aware that this integration exist and i've read a couple of meetings reports related to it on the Equinox wiki, but why bother with the

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread Rahul Thakur
Hi Nicolas, Sorry, I have looked at the recent updates to the code, hence my question. Is this 'ready' enough to be used outside Archiva? I'd like to integrate this into Continuum. I think it might make sense to have this module in Plexus SVN repo - wdyt? Good stuff! Cheers, Rahul nicolas

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread Rahul Thakur
Opps, I meant... I haven't looked at the recent updates to the code... PS: Sorry about the earlier empty msg. /me slaps wrist - need to reinstall my mail client! Rahul On Tue, Feb 26, 2008 at 9:47 AM, Rahul Thakur [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread nicolas de loof
Hi Rahul, Thanks for yout interest for this plexus-to-spring migration helper. The code is still early experimental and requires some more testing : it only has been tested on 2 archiva testcases and requires many fixes and testcases to get stable. Please give me one week to test it more, add

Re: [OT] Re: An experiment with Spring... What about OSGi ?

2008-02-25 Thread Rahul Thakur
OK, this is just my personal opinion: I think choice of Spring OSGi is influenced by a few things: 1) Archiva is looking to garner more contributions from the community. Moving to Spring would, IMO, definately lessen the learning curve. There is a comprehensive documentation and large user

Re: [discuss] Archiva TLP proposal

2008-02-25 Thread James William Dumay
+1 Thanks for starting this discussion Brett. Not being tied to Maven also presents us with the option to grow beyond the scope of a Maven repository manager so what we can support other similar tools if the niche presents itself. On Mon, 2008-02-25 at 13:04 +1100, Brett Porter wrote: Ok,

Re: from plexus to spring...

2008-02-25 Thread Joakim Erdfelt
nicolas, This is way cool! A very slick way of helping the transition. I'm looking forward to some free time to dive into it. - Joakim nicolas de loof wrote: Hi Rahul, Thanks for yout interest for this plexus-to-spring migration helper. The code is still early experimental and requires