RE: Cost benefit analysis

2003-02-14 Thread Driessnack, John
In the Defense Department you have a creative tension environment. The group trying to sell the project must have estimates reviewed independently by groups who don't care about the particular project. The estimates are all compared to the benefits that each system brings to the overall weapons

Re: Cost benefit analysis

2003-02-14 Thread William Dickens
Hi Fred, Yes, that is a good question. I think the answer is that it does take a fairly sophisticated economist to write a cost-benefit analysis, but it doesn't take much savvy to know when one is badly biased. Anyone knowledgeable about the topic - - even if they have only a minimal

Re: Speaking of Illegal Guns and Deterrence

2003-02-14 Thread Misha
They think that criminals like being killed Dave Undis wrote: It seems that most people who think gun control laws deter crime also believe the death penalty doesn't. Can anyone explain this? Original Message Follows From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL

Re: Cost benefit analysis

2003-02-14 Thread Bryan D Caplan
William Dickens wrote: For what its worth, it is the pro-regulation, pro-environment, pro-safety crowd that are the most ardent critics of CBA. If you are a libertarian I think that CBA is more often that not your friend. But that is another story... - - Bill Dickens This is a very

Re: Speaking of Illegal Guns and Deterrence

2003-02-14 Thread john hull
--- Misha [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: They think that criminals like being killed Or perhaps it has to do with the nature of the threat. One would imagine that if murderers thought they had a high probability of being caught, they'd not do the crime. However, an armed victim is a different story,