Re: The ACLU and The Price of Free Speech

2000-12-05 Thread Yann Le Du
On Tue, 5 Dec 2000, Robin Hanson wrote: Fabio Rojas wrote: But I have often wondered if we could measure willingness to pay for various freedoms, perhaps by just directly asking people. ... There are two kinds of free speech whose price we can measure: freedom of one's own speech (I

Re: The ACLU and The Price of Free Speech

2000-12-05 Thread Robin Hanson
Yann Le Du wrote: I agree that many people highly value their ability to express their religion. But how much they value a constitutional guarantee to such expression depends on what they think the chances are that the government would actually try to stop them. ... can't a

Re: The ACLU and The Price of Free Speech

2000-12-05 Thread fabio guillermo rojas
On Tue, 5 Dec 2000, Yann Le Du wrote: Doesn't the _existence_ of the rule participate in changing the way the people "think the chances are that the government would actually try to stop them" ? I think there's a retroaction process there. You might think so, but for the longest time in

Re: The ACLU and The Price of Free Speech

2000-12-05 Thread Yann Le Du
On Tue, 5 Dec 2000, fabio guillermo rojas wrote: On Tue, 5 Dec 2000, Yann Le Du wrote: Doesn't the _existence_ of the rule participate in changing the way the people "think the chances are that the government would actually try to stop them" ? I think there's a retroaction process

The ACLU and The Price of Free Speech

2000-12-04 Thread fabio guillermo rojas
On Mon, 4 Dec 2000, Robin Hanson wrote: But I have often wondered if we could measure willingness to pay for various freedoms, perhaps by just directly asking people. I think we already have one good measure: the amount of donations to organizations dedicated to free speech such as the ACLU.