Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-13 Thread sjostrom
My own guess is that the economy cars look alike because of technology. I moved to Ireland in 1992, before the economy boomed, and there was (to me anyway) a startling homogeneity among the mostly small, cheap cars. All small and boxy. In the last decade, the Irish economy has boomed,

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-13 Thread john hull
--- [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My own guess is that the economy cars look alike because of technology. I asked a former GM engineer with 40 years at the company if there was any engineering reason why all compact cars look the same, even between manufacturers. He couldn't think of any. Granted

Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread Robin Hanson
I went shopping for a compact car recently, and discovered that they are all quite similar - especially their physical shape. This seems remarkable in light of how much cars have varied over the years, and how people supposedly are willing to pay extra for a distinctive car. (And given how

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread Robin Hanson
Fabio wrote: Wouldn't it be easier to produce cheap cars if all models were similar to each other? Ie, you wouldn't need to retool for every model - just make some cosmetic changes and keep the cost low? I think that was the idea behind the Ford Escort first, then other cars like the Hyndais and

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread Eric Crampton
On Mon, 12 Aug 2002, fabio guillermo rojas wrote: Wouldn't it be easier to produce cheap cars if all models were similar to each other? Ie, you wouldn't need to retool for every model - just make some cosmetic changes and keep the cost low? I think that was the idea behind the Ford Escort

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread John A. Viator
When I read this I thought that it must be wrong, since it is well known that a sphere maximizes volume/area. However, if cars traveled through tubes, this would be relevant. Cars, though, travel on planar roads so that a square cross section does maximize interior space. Longitudinal

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread AdmrlLocke
In a message dated 8/12/02 2:42:35 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Wouldn't it be easier to produce cheap cars if all models were similar to each other? Ie, you wouldn't need to retool for every model - just make some cosmetic changes and keep the cost low? I think that was the idea behind the

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread fabio guillermo rojas
That makes sense for the cars all made by the same company, or which share subcontractors. But Toyota, Honda, Subaru, and Ford all make cars with virtually the same shape and layout. Robin Hanson [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://hanson.gmu.edu Among management theory/organizational sociology

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread AdmrlLocke
In a message dated 8/12/02 4:18:25 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Or to rephrase in economic terms, risk averse managers prefer copying a proven strategy (low risk/low payoff) than engaging in RD (high payoff/high risk). Fabio That certainly looked true toward the end of the 1980s, when all

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread Joel Simon Grus
Having just bought a new car, I disagree that compact cars look identical. The Honda Civic I settled on clearly looks like a Honda Civic, and the Ford Focus and Hyundai Elantra I didn't buy each had its own unmistakeable look. Even the new Toyota Corollas and Mazda Proteges I've seen on the

Re: Why Compact Cars Identical?

2002-08-12 Thread fabio guillermo rojas
Or to rephrase in economic terms, risk averse managers prefer copying a proven strategy (low risk/low payoff) than engaging in RD (high payoff/high risk). reduce drag coefficients to increase fuel economy. The summer I sold cars (1997 at a Pontiac-Mazda-Jeep-Eagle dealer) one of the