Re: intellectual property

2003-09-17 Thread Fred Foldvary
--- Barney Hamish [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: How does the market decide that the _thought_ creation belongs to the creator as you state? The publisher includes a contract with the book that states that the seller agrees not to copy the book, and not to transfer it to anyone unless the next owner

Re: intellectual property

2003-09-05 Thread Steve Miller
: So do public/university libraries fundamentally violate intellectual property rights? As you know, copyrights confer only limited rights to the author. Owners of books may rent out the books. Copyright only outlaws copying, not use or lending. Is copying alone an act of theft, or only when

Re: intellectual property

2003-09-05 Thread Steve Miller
Well, as Robert Book pointed out, there is a conflict between laws. The law says fair use, whatever that means exactly, but now the DMCA says not even that. Though the DMCA really only permits the prevention of fair use, I think. But anyway, it's a real stretch to call the current situation a