Re: Unequal Pay Makes Monkeys go Ape

2003-09-23 Thread Susan Hogarth
On Tuesday 23 September 2003 05:50 pm, Michael Giesbrecht wrote:
 It ocurred to me, after reading Susan Hogarth's observation of the
 walloping touch of bias in science reporting revealed in the first
 sentence, that I should have asked: So, can anybody tell me what economic
 school of thought the monkey researchers adhere to? Maybe their research
 tells us more about them than it does about the monkeys.

How funny! That was exactly the comment I had intended to make, but I thought
it was too obvious. I guess I was right :)

--
Susan Hogarth
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.tribeagles.org


Re: Unequal Pay Makes Monkeys go Ape

2003-09-22 Thread Susan Hogarth
Quoting Michael Giesbrecht [EMAIL PROTECTED]:

 So, can anybody tell me economic school of thought monkeys adhere to? ;-)


 http://www.abc.net.au/science/news/scitech/SciTechRepublish_948138.htm

 Unequal pay makes monkeys go ape
 Thursday, 18 September 2003

 Monkeys, like humans, are acutely aware of injustice, which suggests that a
 sense of equality is an ancestral trait among primates, a study says.

 In an unusual two-year experiment, animal behaviourists Sarah Brosnan and
 Frans de Waal of Emory University in Atlanta, Georgia, taught brown capuchin
 monkeys to receive tokens as a reward and to barter them for food.

 The monkeys were usually quite content to swap the tokens for cucumber but if
 the researchers gave one of the monkeys a grape, a more eagerly-sought food,
 the other animals would become jealous.

 Some of them refused to hand over their tokens. Others would still exchange
 their token for the cucumber but scornfully decline to eat it.

cut

Note that (IN THE VERY FIRST SENTENCE) the writer labels the differential
trades as an instance of *injustice*. Nothing like a walloping touch of bias in
science reporting, especially when comparing humans to apes.

Getting *away* from that ancestral sense of equality is probably what got man
out of the trees in the first place.

Scornfully decline? How could the researcher or the reporter possibly know
such a thing?

--
Susan Hogarth
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.tribeagles.org


Re: Unequal Pay Makes Monkeys go Ape

2003-09-22 Thread Susan Hogarth
Quoting Tigger [EMAIL PROTECTED]:

 PS.  I wonder if others have the new problem that a simple MS Outlook
 Express Reply
 does not go to the Armchair address (so I had to copy  paste)?

Try 'reply all'. If you want to be very nice, you can take the original sender
out of the 'To:' line and drag the list name there (from the 'cc' line) instead.

--
Susan Hogarth
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.tribeagles.org