Re: new paper

2004-03-24 Thread Wei Dai
On Thu, Mar 11, 2004 at 01:44:42PM -0500, Bryan Caplan wrote: My new paper on the economics of mental illness, entitled The Economics of Szasz can now be downloaded from my webpage at: http://www.gmu.edu/departments/economics/bcaplan/szaszjhe.doc The paper makes the point that what psychology

Re: insanity vs. irrationality

2004-03-24 Thread Robert A. Book
On Mar 24, 2004, at 8:33 AM, Wei Dai wrote The paper makes the point that what psychology views as mental diseases in many cases can be interpreted simply as extreme or unusual preferences, and in those cases involuntary psychiatric treatment can not be justified as a benefit for the

Re: insanity vs. irrationality

2004-03-24 Thread AdmrlLocke
What about the person, like an alcoholic or schizophrenic, who hates his extreme preferences, as they destroy his life? Setting aside the issue of involuntary treatment for the benefit of others, as we really talking only about a case of extreme preference? David Levenstam In a message dated

Is Manipulation Good?

2004-03-24 Thread Robin Hanson
Since the precedent has been set, let me advertise my new paper: --- http://hanson.gmu.edu/biashelp.pdf Manipulators Increase Information Market Accuracy by Robin Hanson and Ryan Oprea, March 2004

Re: insanity vs. irrationality

2004-03-24 Thread Stephen Miller
I can try, and hope that people will correct me where I'm wrong. Thin rationality: purposiveness; adopting means to achieve given ends. Another aspect is having *some* level of sensitivity to costs and benefits. A violation of thin rationality would be if you knew that blinking didn't change