Shahnavas,
The conclusion that you have come to, is doubly applicable to you than to
anyone out here. Good luck.
On 2/7/08, Dinesh [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Well said,bro :) i second this.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com,
That is one, thinking, mature a r r fan speaking!!
Bull's eye, Wasim bhai !! :-)
Regards,
-Vishwesh.
kaissiom [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
This has turned out to be one of the longest threads in recent memory.
It all comes down to personal opinions, but I look at it this way..
The songs from Mangal Pandey were good . I liked most of the songs from that
film except Holi song . Where as Guru is concerned even those songs were
criticised by portion of people . Though songs from Guru ruled the charts in
North but i dont think it created similar magic down south . But for
atm was created to strike chord with the masses whilst JA was created for the
elite. thats why ATM was a success in audio sales.
ariff
Triply R. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Not sure who this was addressed to, but obviously
being the guy who dissed ATM and said JA and MP were
good, I
...dnt use the words like this sucks or that sucks for the
music...
Music is our god we worship it...
if u didnt like it...dnt listen to it..or atleast criticize wid descent
wordings...
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Tue, 5 Feb 2008 23:01:51
-0800Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Jodha Akbar
for people telling ATm Sucks... I am sorry. Pls come to CHENNAI, SOUTH INDia
and then you will realise the greatness of the craze for ATM songs. FM
Radios are having a race to broadcast ATM songs .The more the number of
times, the songs from ATM are played, the more the people are listening. ATM
The music still sucks and not one song is worth it!
- lol, this was a good 1! just becoz u said MP songs r better than
ATM, im not gonna accept u as a quality music admirer. Yes, ATM is a
mass album, but thats really silly to say ATM songs sucks. goodness,
and this coming from an ARR fan?? maybe
I had a feeling that nobody liked Mangal Pandey and Parasuram
albums.But from this discussion i understand that many people liked
the songs very much. I also understand from this discussion that there
is no point in comparing two music pieces, it wont reach anywhere.so
if you like a song add
This has turned out to be one of the longest threads in recent memory.
It all comes down to personal opinions, but I look at it this way..
Would you rather had Rahman not make any music for 'Parasuram' or
'Mangal Pandey' or 'Dil Se' or 'substitute any album here'?
I cherish Parasuram and Mangal
Well said,bro :) i second this.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, shanavas.chemmamkuzhi
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
I had a feeling that nobody liked Mangal Pandey and Parasuram
albums.But from this discussion i understand that many people liked
the songs very much. I also
Dear Arun,
Shanavas has nt it takes time to grow..
He said it is bad!!!..
Please clarify wat u meant..
Regards,
S.V.Nagaraj
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, arunblore69 [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
Hi All,
i support Shanavas and all please...we are here to share wht
all we really
In south, the music sales is depends on the actors. Most of the
Rajani and Vijay songs were super hits. But in hindi, music wont
sell due to actors.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Dinesh [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
Just to justify ur like for Mangal JA doesnt mean u can go on
bashing
Not sure who this was addressed to, but obviously
being the guy who dissed ATM and said JA and MP were
good, I assume it is addressed to me! Well, for one,
yup, you can say I am super ignorant since I still
feel ATM sucked. It may have gotten better reviews
than JA but heck, every review is just
Pls never say ARR did any worst album or stuff like that. This is a forum
for admiring ARR. if you do not like some songs, its your personal taste,
and may be you can keep that opinion with yourselves, instead of hurting
other's sentiments
How can you claim that its worst and things like
Dear Shanavas,
I strongly disgree..
I feel none of ARR albums are bad as I have enjoyed almost
everyone of them.
For ex in parasuram i liked Kathal Vettukili,Mupathu nimidam,
Dolna.. Three were really good..just may take somemore time
to grow.. Parasuram had very bad publicity.. So it was not
Sorry for that word. I will be careful in future posts.
-Shanavas
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Vithur [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Pls never say ARR did any worst album or stuff like that. This is
a forum
for admiring ARR. if you do not like some songs, its your personal
taste,
and
with Lakes.
Long Live ARR and his ardent fan like Vithur.
Thanks,
SHAIK MAHABOOB
- Original Message
From: jamshid TC [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Monday, February 4, 2008 2:08:47 PM
Subject: Re: [arr] Re: Jodha Akbar is another Mangal Pandey
Hi All,
i support Shanavas and all please...we are here to share wht
all we really njoied of our Maestro and i dont think that any of the
songs or albums were bad..as Shanavas said it takes time to
grow...thats it..so njoi it more...
Arun
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Nagaraj
Just to justify ur like for Mangal JA doesnt mean u can go on
bashing ATM, for ur KIND information, ATM album was 1 of the biggest
hit ALBUM last year in Tamil, infact it did more wonders than Sivaji
audio. unless ur being super ignorant, then i have no idea. well, yea,
even i enjoyed ATM more
Thanks for your opinion representing a very, very miniscule minority.
Have a blast with ATM, whch by the way, has a few good numbers. The
rest of us will relish JA.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Subramanian H K [EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
enjoy ATM till the next album releases..
ATM and JA are both on different leagues. Both are for different
types of audience. Rahman cant give either one of them everytime.
Mangal Pandey was a good musical album too. The film wasnt a success,
and its not Rahman's responsibility. JA is a super duper album, and I
dont wish to know what
How right you are!! I haven't enjoyed a Hindi Rahman
album as much as JA since Mangal Pandey! Both of them
are really excellent albums and 2 things that
vindicate my stance as a Rahman fan!
By the way, what is ATM? Oh wait, isn't it that new
Vijay album that was supposed to release sometime last
I feel so proud when so many of you dont like JA or Mangal pandey for that
matter.
Makes me feel special, cuz then there is someting only arr and I share :)
On Feb 4, 2008 6:52 AM, Sai [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
ATM and JA are both on different leagues. Both are for different
types of
I dont think there is different types of audience. Good music is
always good music.
Film's success is not depend on film's music, but Mangal Pandey
music was a huge disappointment.
As per the sales and popularity, JA is not a super duper album.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sai
I think you forget one album between Thenali and ATM
Parasuram - AR's worst album ever.
--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Triply R.
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
How right you are!! I haven't enjoyed a Hindi Rahman
album as much as JA since Mangal Pandey! Both of them
are really excellent
25 matches
Mail list logo
