Re: [arr] ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''

[Jahanzeb]

Yeah glad to see some sensible comments. and yes it is surprising to read what 
Anu said. I see some change in his attitude. earlier too (I don't remember 
when, maybe on his Oscar wins) he said some very positive things about ARR. 


/Jahanzeb

--- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Roshan  wrote:
>
> there are some sensible comments here. and I was most surprised about Anu
> Malik's comment. he sounds so mature and sensible here unlike what i used to
> read in the 90s.
> 
> well, at least there is a bunch of people who understand all these
> 
> On Thu, Sep 2, 2010 at 12:07 PM, A.R.Rajib  wrote:
> 
> >
> >
> >  ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''
> > ibnlive.com 
> > Posted on *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:00* | Updated *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:56*
> >
> >   [image: 
> > Email]
> > [image: Print]
> > 66Share
> >  1
> >
> > The industry is abuzz with the recent news that the *Commonwealth 
> > Games*
> > ** officials now want A R Rahman's Rs 5 crore theme track *Swagatham* to
> > be 'recomposed'. Fellow musicians talk to IBNLive about their reactions to
> > the rumours...
> >
> >  Singer Shaan feels that Rahman as a composer has his own beliefs about his
> > compositions. Shaan says, "Rahman generally takes a brief and takes it ahead
> > from there. What I would like to say is that the CWG officials should work
> > on their own shortcomings and pull their act together." He adds, "We are so
> > scared of getting humiliated in front of the whole world with the CWG. Don't
> > waste time finding faults in Rahman."
> >
> >  Kavita 
> > *Krishnamurthy*
> > ** has been busy traveling and admits she hasn't had the time to hear
> > Rahman's composition. However, she points out, "For any composer, for
> > example if my husband has been commissioned to compose a song...from the
> > beginning to the end, the organizers are always involved. While the entire
> > song is taking shape, they (organizers) are involved. If there are certain
> > changes to be made, the composer should have been alerted from step one."
> > She adds emphatically, "It is bad for the reputation of any musician. It is
> > very hurting."
> >
> >  [image: A R Rahman at an event]
> >
> >  Music director *Anu 
> > Malik*
> > ** has not heard *Swagatham* either. He, however, explains, "I have not
> > heard the song but the broader thing is…Rahman is a gifted composer. It all
> > depends on what brief had been given to him. For the kind of money that has
> > been paid (reportedly 5 crore), it is a huge amount. I am sure if Rahman has
> > composed the theme track, it must be very good. But if something takes about
> > four, five or six months, was the brief given in the first place OK? The net
> > reaction to the track has not been that good. At the end of the day, Indians
> > are very emotional towards their music."
> >
> >  Music director Bappi Lahiri admits he has not heard the song. He says, "I
> > have not heard the song yet and therefore would not like to comment on the
> > matter."
> >
> >  By Sujata Chakrabarti
> >
> >
> >
> > http://ibnlive.in.com/news/it-is-bad-for-the-reputation-of-any-musician/130081-8-75.html
> > --
> > *- Regards
> >
> > ~ ~ A.R.Rajib ~ ~*
> >
> >  
> >
> 
> 
> 
> -- 
> ---
> http://roshanravi.com
> http://ramblingsoul.com
> http://cssheaven.org
>

Re: [arr] ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''

[Manaf]

Hi Roshan

He has changed himself totally... I don't what will be the comments of
Nadeem - Shravan .

On Thu, Sep 2, 2010 at 4:46 PM, Roshan  wrote:

>
>
> there are some sensible comments here. and I was most surprised about Anu
> Malik's comment. he sounds so mature and sensible here unlike what i used to
> read in the 90s.
>
> well, at least there is a bunch of people who understand all these
>
>
> On Thu, Sep 2, 2010 at 12:07 PM, A.R.Rajib  wrote:
>
>>
>>
>>  ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''
>> ibnlive.com 
>> Posted on *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:00* | Updated *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:56*
>>
>>   [image: 
>> Email]
>> [image: Print]
>> 66Share
>>  1
>>
>> The industry is abuzz with the recent news that the *Commonwealth 
>> Games*
>> ** officials now want A R Rahman's Rs 5 crore theme track *Swagatham* to
>> be 'recomposed'. Fellow musicians talk to IBNLive about their reactions to
>> the rumours...
>>
>>  Singer Shaan feels that Rahman as a composer has his own beliefs about
>> his compositions. Shaan says, “Rahman generally takes a brief and takes it
>> ahead from there. What I would like to say is that the CWG officials should
>> work on their own shortcomings and pull their act together.” He adds, “We
>> are so scared of getting humiliated in front of the whole world with the
>> CWG. Don’t waste time finding faults in Rahman.”
>>
>>  Kavita 
>> *Krishnamurthy*
>> ** has been busy traveling and admits she hasn’t had the time to hear
>> Rahman’s composition. However, she points out, “For any composer, for
>> example if my husband has been commissioned to compose a song...from the
>> beginning to the end, the organizers are always involved. While the entire
>> song is taking shape, they (organizers) are involved. If there are certain
>> changes to be made, the composer should have been alerted from step one.”
>> She adds emphatically, “It is bad for the reputation of any musician. It is
>> very hurting.”
>>
>>  [image: A R Rahman at an event]
>>
>>  Music director *Anu 
>> Malik*
>> ** has not heard *Swagatham* either. He, however, explains, “I have not
>> heard the song but the broader thing is…Rahman is a gifted composer. It all
>> depends on what brief had been given to him. For the kind of money that has
>> been paid (reportedly 5 crore), it is a huge amount. I am sure if Rahman has
>> composed the theme track, it must be very good. But if something takes about
>> four, five or six months, was the brief given in the first place OK? The net
>> reaction to the track has not been that good. At the end of the day, Indians
>> are very emotional towards their music.”
>>
>>  Music director Bappi Lahiri admits he has not heard the song. He says, “I
>> have not heard the song yet and therefore would not like to comment on the
>> matter.”
>>
>>  By Sujata Chakrabarti
>>
>>
>>
>> http://ibnlive.in.com/news/it-is-bad-for-the-reputation-of-any-musician/130081-8-75.html
>> --
>> *- Regards
>>
>> ~ ~ A.R.Rajib ~ ~*
>>
>>
>
>
> --
> ---
> http://roshanravi.com
> http://ramblingsoul.com
> http://cssheaven.org
>
>  
>



-- 
*
*
*Regards

*
*MANAF

*

Re: [arr] ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''

[Roshan]

there are some sensible comments here. and I was most surprised about Anu
Malik's comment. he sounds so mature and sensible here unlike what i used to
read in the 90s.

well, at least there is a bunch of people who understand all these

On Thu, Sep 2, 2010 at 12:07 PM, A.R.Rajib  wrote:

>
>
>  ''It is bad for the reputation of any musician''
> ibnlive.com 
> Posted on *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:00* | Updated *Sep 01, 2010 at 15:56*
>
>   [image: 
> Email]
> [image: Print]
> 66Share
>  1
>
> The industry is abuzz with the recent news that the *Commonwealth 
> Games*
> ** officials now want A R Rahman's Rs 5 crore theme track *Swagatham* to
> be 'recomposed'. Fellow musicians talk to IBNLive about their reactions to
> the rumours...
>
>  Singer Shaan feels that Rahman as a composer has his own beliefs about his
> compositions. Shaan says, “Rahman generally takes a brief and takes it ahead
> from there. What I would like to say is that the CWG officials should work
> on their own shortcomings and pull their act together.” He adds, “We are so
> scared of getting humiliated in front of the whole world with the CWG. Don’t
> waste time finding faults in Rahman.”
>
>  Kavita 
> *Krishnamurthy*
> ** has been busy traveling and admits she hasn’t had the time to hear
> Rahman’s composition. However, she points out, “For any composer, for
> example if my husband has been commissioned to compose a song...from the
> beginning to the end, the organizers are always involved. While the entire
> song is taking shape, they (organizers) are involved. If there are certain
> changes to be made, the composer should have been alerted from step one.”
> She adds emphatically, “It is bad for the reputation of any musician. It is
> very hurting.”
>
>  [image: A R Rahman at an event]
>
>  Music director *Anu 
> Malik*
> ** has not heard *Swagatham* either. He, however, explains, “I have not
> heard the song but the broader thing is…Rahman is a gifted composer. It all
> depends on what brief had been given to him. For the kind of money that has
> been paid (reportedly 5 crore), it is a huge amount. I am sure if Rahman has
> composed the theme track, it must be very good. But if something takes about
> four, five or six months, was the brief given in the first place OK? The net
> reaction to the track has not been that good. At the end of the day, Indians
> are very emotional towards their music.”
>
>  Music director Bappi Lahiri admits he has not heard the song. He says, “I
> have not heard the song yet and therefore would not like to comment on the
> matter.”
>
>  By Sujata Chakrabarti
>
>
>
> http://ibnlive.in.com/news/it-is-bad-for-the-reputation-of-any-musician/130081-8-75.html
> --
> *- Regards
>
> ~ ~ A.R.Rajib ~ ~*
>
>  
>



-- 
---
http://roshanravi.com
http://ramblingsoul.com
http://cssheaven.org