Re: [arts-dev] Scattering calculations when the cloud box is switched off

2017-06-13 Thread Jana Mendrok
Hi, So, in the specific issue raised by Jacob, I vote for simply going back to > the old behaviour. It is formally correct to get a clear sky result in a > calculation without cloud box, rolled that back (for all doit, disort, and rt4 interfaces). > so let’s trust the user that he knows what

Re: [arts-dev] Scattering calculations when the cloud box is switched off

2017-06-07 Thread Patrick Eriksson
Hi Jana and Jakob , hi all, Before commenting on this particular questions, I see a more general discussion here. There are many similar issues. Shall we focus on catching potential user mistakes/misunderstandings, or be less restrictive to simplify batch/operational processing? For example,

[arts-dev] Scattering calculations when the cloud box is switched off

2017-06-07 Thread Jakob Sd
Hi, recently there has been a change in the way DOIT and DISORT handle atmospheres where the cloud box is switched off (cloudbox_on = 0). Before, they just skipped the scattering calculation, threw a warning, and everything was ok, as the clear-sky calculations afterwards took care of it. But