RE: [Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-03 Thread Chris Bagnall
I am planning to connect my Asterisk PBX to one or two POTS lines, and am wondering if it is better to use a TDM card for this, or one or two SIP devices with FXO ports on them (such as an SPA-3000, Grandstream 488). I think it largely depends on where you're located and how much work has

Re: [Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-03 Thread Walt Reed
I've had issues with the FXO port on the spa3000 - banking apps could not hear the DTMF. I've also had problems with phones hooked up to the TDM FXS ports where banking apps hear DOUBLE dtmf digits. The only mix that seems to work for me is SIP phones / or analog phones hooked up to ATA's and TDM

Re: [Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-03 Thread Rich Adamson
I've had issues with the FXO port on the spa3000 - banking apps could not hear the DTMF. I've also had problems with phones hooked up to the TDM FXS ports where banking apps hear DOUBLE dtmf digits. The only mix that seems to work for me is SIP phones / or analog phones hooked up to ATA's

RE: [Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-03 Thread Chris Bagnall
This is a very interesting thread. Could folks posting their experiences please also post the country their experiences relate to? Regards, Chris -- C.M. Bagnall, Director, Minotaur I.T. Limited This email is made from 100% recycled electrons ___

Re: [Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-03 Thread John Daragon
Chris Bagnall wrote: This is a very interesting thread. Could folks posting their experiences please also post the country their experiences relate to? We've had very good experience with the SPA-3000 in the UK since the last version of the firmware sorted out local impedance settings

[Asterisk-Users] TDM0xB vs. SIP for FXO

2005-11-02 Thread Rusty Dekema
Hi, I am planning to connect my Asterisk PBX to one or two POTS lines, and am wondering if it is better to use a TDM card for this, or one or two SIP devices with FXO ports on them (such as an SPA-3000, Grandstream 488). I am interested in voice quality and reliability of operation and am