Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread Leif Madsen
On 10-09-23 05:40 PM, cov...@ccs.covici.com wrote: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and when I hit mute on the softphone, all rtp traffic

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread Benny Amorsen
cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and when I hit mute on the softphone, all rtp traffic ceases! Now, a version

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread covici
Leif Madsen leif.mad...@asteriskdocs.org wrote: On 10-09-23 05:40 PM, cov...@ccs.covici.com wrote: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread covici
Benny Amorsen benny+use...@amorsen.dk wrote: cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and when I hit mute on the

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread Lyle Giese
Benny Amorsen wrote: cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and when I hit mute on the softphone, all rtp traffic

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread covici
Lyle Giese l...@lcrcomputer.net wrote: Benny Amorsen wrote: cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread Philipp von Klitzing
Hi! Why is it a problem? It sounds like Asterisk does silence suppression. 1) With no rtp traffic, the nat device will drop the connection in it's nat table and thus disconnecting the softphone from Asterisk. (after the router's timeout period of course) 2) The other issue is you are

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread covici
Philipp von Klitzing klitz...@pool.informatik.rwth-aachen.de wrote: Hi! Why is it a problem? It sounds like Asterisk does silence suppression. 1) With no rtp traffic, the nat device will drop the connection in it's nat table and thus disconnecting the softphone from Asterisk. (after

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread Benny Amorsen
cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: But it surpresses in both directions! I still want to hear the other end. For a test is there a way to turn off that feature to see if that is the cause? Ah, so it isn't Asterisk doing silence suppression, it's Asterisk being unable to handle that other devices

Re: [asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-24 Thread covici
All I have to do to make it work is to use 1.8.0 revision 281875 -- after that something is broke. I was hoping someone could look and see what changed just after that rev and see if it makes sense. Benny Amorsen benny+use...@amorsen.dk wrote: cov...@ccs.covici.com writes: But it

[asterisk-users] rtp problem with 1.8.0-rdc1

2010-09-23 Thread covici
Hi. I am having a very strange problem --aren't they all -- with the release candidate. I have softphone which talks to asterisk from behind nat -- the asterisk is on a public ip -- and when I hit mute on the softphone, all rtp traffic ceases! Now, a version which does work is r281875, this