Re: [Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-22 Thread Lonnie Abelbeck
Hi Michael, > The explanation of ‘Applies to all outbound traffic to/from the Hosts’ was a > little confusing! Agreed. That could be written better. Indeed, most all the traffic shaping is for the Uplink case, and normally I recommend the "Downlink Speed:" be set to [ Disabled ] . With that

Re: [Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-22 Thread Michael Knill
Thanks Lonnie and others. Interesting that its both ways. The explanation of ‘Applies to all outbound traffic to/from the Hosts’ was a little confusing! When I activated the inbound shaper, it shaped all traffic INCLUDING my media which obviously caused more packet loss. So if I was to use SHA

Re: [Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-22 Thread Lonnie Abelbeck
Throttling inbound traffic is often not much practical use since that commonly involves just dropping packets, packets that *could* have been handled. Special cases like guest WiFi access points, dropping packets is probably fine, which can be commonly done in the external AP itself. As far as

Re: [Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-22 Thread David Kerr
Lonnie, I think Michael is asking about limiting inbound traffic, not outbound. The SHAPER_P2P_HOSTS setting I think only applies to outbound traffic... because as you state we implemented it for the case where you have a NAS server on local network uploading to a cloud-based backup and we wanted

Re: [Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-22 Thread Lonnie Abelbeck
Hi Michael, I think what you are asking is: "I want to shape all traffic on the external interface such that all forwarded traffic has lower priority than any internal traffic." In general, you are better off shaping the traffic "type" rather than traffic "source/destination", which is how our

[Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping again

2016-01-21 Thread Michael Knill
Yes more Traffic Shaping questions sorry. Is there any way that I can shape certain traffic types only for Downstream? Basically I want to be able to shape all other traffic incoming EXCEPT with a destination of the Asterisk server EXT interface. Is this possible? Regards Michael Knill

[Astlinux-users] Traffic Shaping

2015-01-09 Thread Michael Knill
Hi Group Just looking at the Traffic Shaping Plugin and previous posts. I just wanted to check that the SHAPER defined Ports determine the drop priority WITHIN the shaped envelope and RTP traffic is outside of the shaped envelope. Is this correct? Thanks Michael Knill -