Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-12 Thread Ernest Prabhakar
On Feb 9, 2007, at 9:23 PM, John Panzer wrote: Does anyone know of any issues with placing Yahoo! Media RSS extensions (which seem to fit the requirments for Atom extensions to me) inside an Atom feed? Secondarily A year or two ago there was discussion of doing an IETF working group to

Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-12 Thread James M Snell
I'd be all for it assuming it didn't go off in the weeds. - James Ernest Prabhakar wrote: On Feb 9, 2007, at 9:23 PM, John Panzer wrote: Does anyone know of any issues with placing Yahoo! Media RSS extensions (which seem to fit the requirments for Atom extensions to me) inside an Atom

Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-10 Thread James Holderness
John Panzer wrote: Does anyone know of any issues with placing Yahoo! Media RSS extensions (which seem to fit the requirments for Atom extensions to me) inside an Atom feed? Secondarily, do feed readers in general recognize MRSS inside either Atom or RSS? Looking for field

Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-10 Thread James M Snell
That's a big assumption. The only reason I added it to Abdera was to prove a point about being able to support RSS extensions in Atom. I haven't come across any implementation that makes use of the extensions. - James James Holderness wrote: [snip] That said, I know there are feed libraries

Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-10 Thread Antone Roundy
On Feb 9, 2007, at 9:23 PM, John Panzer wrote: Does anyone know of any issues with placing Yahoo! Media RSS extensions (which seem to fit the requirments for Atom extensions to me) inside an Atom feed? Secondarily, do feed readers in general recognize MRSS inside either Atom or RSS?

Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-09 Thread John Panzer
Does anyone know of any issues with placing Yahoo! Media RSS extensions (which seem to fit the requirments for Atom extensions to me) inside an Atom feed? Secondarily, do feed readers in general recognize MRSS inside either Atom or RSS? Looking for field experience/implementor intentions here.

Re: Query re: support of Media RSS extensions inside Atom feeds

2007-02-09 Thread James M Snell
I'm not sure if there are any feed readers that support MRSS in Atom but I don't see any reason why it wouldn't work. A while back I implemented minimal support for the MRSS extensions in Abdera with very little difficulty. - James John Panzer wrote: Does anyone know of any issues with