Re: PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-07 Thread James M Snell
Paul Hoffman wrote: > > -1 because it doesn't feel like it belongs in the core. That is, when > more developers have real profiles that they want to differentiate from > the atom core, adding a @profile attribute seems like a good extension. Hmm. the challenge with this assertion is that the atom s

PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-07 Thread Paul Hoffman
-1 because it doesn't feel like it belongs in the core. That is, when more developers have real profiles that they want to differentiate from the atom core, adding a @profile attribute seems like a good extension. --Paul Hoffman, Director --Internet Mail Consortium

Re: PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-07 Thread Antone Roundy
I'm in favor of profiles, just -1 to allowing @profile on sub-elements. So I prefer PaceProfile to PaceProfileAttribute. On Monday, February 7, 2005, at 02:17 PM, James M Snell wrote: This is entirely possible also. Just to be clear tho, you're not -1'ing the idea of pro

Re: PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-07 Thread James M Snell
This is entirely possible also. Just to be clear tho, you're not -1'ing the idea of profiles, just the allowing of the @profile attribute on sub-elements (e.g. entries contained in feeds) correct? This is an important distinction because I'm definitely not married to the syntax as presented b

PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-07 Thread Antone Roundy
-1: One profile (or maybe set of profiles) per document is better in my opinion. If an aggregator aggregates entries with different profiles, it can either fix them up as needed to conform to a common profile, or if multiple profiles can be specified at the top level, declare the profiles for

Re: New: PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-05 Thread Eric Scheid
On 6/2/05 10:53 AM, "James M Snell" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > atom:feed and atom:entry elements MAY have a "profile" attribute whose > value is a list of names or URI's identifying one or more metadata > profiles that have been applied to the feed or entry. A profile is a > description what m

New: PaceProfileAttribute

2005-02-05 Thread James M Snell
This is a modified version of Mark Nottingham's initial idea that reflects my thinking on the subject as developed through the mailing list discussion. I posted it as PaceProfileAttribute as opposed to Mark's initial PaceProfile in case he wanted to go ahead and attempt to submit hi