Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-07 Thread Eran Chinthaka
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 David Illsley wrote: I'm dead against moving security out of the axis2 build and leaving a substantial amount of security tests in the axis2 builds. The converse to an earlier argument is also true, namely that axis2 becomes dependant on rampart

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-07 Thread Ajith Ranabahu
Hi, I have to agree 100% on the effectiveness of the integration tests, specially the ones with security and I know in many cases we ended up finding bugs in non-security code due to the security tests. In effect it means that these tests need to be there somewhere to run constantly to figure out

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-02 Thread David Illsley
I'm dead against moving security out of the axis2 build and leaving a substantial amount of security tests in the axis2 builds. The converse to an earlier argument is also true, namely that axis2 becomes dependant on rampart to build and that people working on rampart won't see the axis2 build

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-02 Thread Davanum Srinivas
David/Team, +1 to move security tests out of Axis2 build +1 to setup continuum on ws.zones thanks, dims On 1/2/07, David Illsley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm dead against moving security out of the axis2 build and leaving a substantial amount of security tests in the axis2 builds. The

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-02 Thread Ruchith Fernando
+1 Thanks, Ruchith On 1/2/07, Davanum Srinivas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: David/Team, +1 to move security tests out of Axis2 build +1 to setup continuum on ws.zones thanks, dims On 1/2/07, David Illsley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm dead against moving security out of the axis2 build and

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-02 Thread Thilina Gunarathne
+1 to setup continuum on ws.zones . I was about to propose it and David beat me :).. IMHO we should configure Continuum to run Axis2 build followed by new security build after every commit to either of the projects. It should send a mail to Axis2-dev with reference to the relevant commit's

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Deepal Jayasinghe
+1 , Thanks Deepal Ruchith Fernando wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this new project Rampart and include code from

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Ruchith Fernando
Deepal, Do you think we have tests to cover the axis2 functionality that those test covers? If so or if someone volunteers to write some then lets remove the rampart integration tests. Thanks, Ruchith On 1/1/07, Deepal Jayasinghe [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I think its better if we can move

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Eran Chinthaka
I think I mentioned this couple of times earlier also. Security tests provide very good integration tests for Axis2 and if you have developed Axis2, those are the hard tests to get passed when you are doing changes. Yes, I agree that we didn't have Axis2 specific tests to cover most of the

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Glen Daniels
The security tests are among the slowest integration tests that we've got. If there's a way, as Ruchith and Deepal mention, to actually test the same Axis2 functionality without the full security machinery, that would serve two purposes - speeding up the build and also more cleanly reducing

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Rajith Attapattu
+1 from me Rajith On 1/1/07, Glen Daniels [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The security tests are among the slowest integration tests that we've got. If there's a way, as Ruchith and Deepal mention, to actually test the same Axis2 functionality without the full security machinery, that would serve

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2007-01-01 Thread Eran Chinthaka
Glen Daniels wrote: The security tests are among the slowest integration tests that we've got. If there's a way, as Ruchith and Deepal mention, to actually test the same Axis2 functionality without the full security machinery, that would serve two purposes - speeding up the build and also

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-31 Thread Ruchith Fernando
I prefer to leave the tests in axs2 since they do test a lot of axis2 stuff such as xmlbeans codegen, holding and accessing properties on context hierarchy, etc. I will have those + some more tests in the new rampart project. Thanks, Ruchith On 12/30/06, Thilina Gunarathne [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-31 Thread Kaushalye Kapuruge
Ruchith Fernando wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this new project Rampart and include code from rampart, rahas and

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-31 Thread Dimuthu Leelaratne
On 1/1/07, Kaushalye Kapuruge [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Ruchith Fernando wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this new

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-31 Thread Amila Suriarachchi
+1 -- Amila Suriarachchi, WSO2 Inc.

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-31 Thread Afkham Azeez
+1 On 12/29/06, Ruchith Fernando [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this new project Rampart and include

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-30 Thread Ajith Ranabahu
+1 -- Ajith Ranabahu - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-30 Thread Sanka Samaranayke
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 +1 Thanks, Sanka Ruchith Fernando wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-30 Thread Jochen Wiedmann
Ruchith Fernando wrote: I propose we call this new project Rampart and include code from rampart, rahas and secpolicy maven modules of axis2. These will be called rampart-core, rampart-trust and rampart-policy respectively. Here's my +1 +1 -- My wife Mary and I have been married for

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Paul Fremantle
+1 from me. Paul On 12/29/06, Davanum Srinivas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me. It's time :) -- dims On 12/29/06, Ruchith Fernando [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a

[Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Ruchith Fernando
Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this new project Rampart and include code from rampart, rahas and secpolicy maven modules of

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Davanum Srinivas
+1 from me. It's time :) -- dims On 12/29/06, Ruchith Fernando [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi All, We released Rampart-1.1 on the 10th December and I think it is time to get all rampart related code out of Axis2 into a new sub-project of the Apache Web services project. I propose we call this

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Chuck Williams
+1 Chuck David Illsley wrote on 12/29/2006 05:44 AM: +1 from me. David On 29/12/06, Paul Fremantle [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me. Paul On 12/29/06, Davanum Srinivas [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me. It's time :) -- dims On 12/29/06, Ruchith Fernando [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Thilina Gunarathne
+1 from me too.. BTW what are your plans for the integration tests... ~Thilina On 12/30/06, Chuck Williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 Chuck David Illsley wrote on 12/29/2006 05:44 AM: +1 from me. David On 29/12/06, Paul Fremantle [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me. Paul On

Re: [Axix2] [Vote] Move rampart, rahas and secpolicy modules of axis2 out into a new project

2006-12-29 Thread Chamikara Jayalath
+1 Chamikara On 12/30/06, Thilina Gunarathne [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me too.. BTW what are your plans for the integration tests... ~Thilina On 12/30/06, Chuck Williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 Chuck David Illsley wrote on 12/29/2006 05:44 AM: +1 from me. David