Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread Arno Lehmann
Hi, 13.10.2009 10:08, justAck wrote: Hi, I still have to learn bacula internals, but urgently need answer for question regarding fragmentation of restored file(s). Perhaps someone did backup of heavily fragmented file (size: ~100G) and then restored it to clean XFS volume on idle box.

Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread Tullio Andreatta ML
justAck wrote: The problem is that copying of restored file is ~20% slower than expected (than other files), I doubt if bacula may be a reason of this slowdown (e.g. result of restore is very fragmented). Fragmentation is not a performance problem on Unix-like filesystems. Sparseness is (see

Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread justAck
Arno, Arno Lehmann wrote: ... a) result file will be most likely not fragmented on disk at all This is most likely in the situation you outline. ... The most common reasons for slow restores, in my experience, are ... Thanks for quick and useful help. I meant file access _after_

Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread Arno Lehmann
Hello, 13.10.2009 14:27, justAck wrote: Arno, Arno Lehmann wrote: ... a) result file will be most likely not fragmented on disk at all This is most likely in the situation you outline. ... The most common reasons for slow restores, in my experience, are ... Thanks for quick and

Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread Arno Lehmann
Hi again, 13.10.2009 20:35, Arno Lehmann wrote: Hello, 13.10.2009 14:27, justAck wrote: Arno, Arno Lehmann wrote: ... Maybe some cache is involved, need to test deeper, just wanted feedback about possible scenarios. See above - I'd try vmstat 1 during a restore and subsequent read

Re: [Bacula-users] Fragmentation of restored file

2009-10-13 Thread Bruno Friedmann
justAck wrote: Hi, I still have to learn bacula internals, but urgently need answer for question regarding fragmentation of restored file(s). Perhaps someone did backup of heavily fragmented file (size: ~100G) and then restored it to clean XFS volume on idle box. What is more likely: a)