Hi Sami,
Yes, I think there is a bit of hand-waving about the S-PE discovery and this DF
election ☺ so clarification would be appreciated.
Also, if the ES is manually set, couldn’t the following work instead of the
described text?:
- The S-PEs send an ES route for the configured ESI, with RT=
Hi Jorge,
The ES is that case will be set manually by the operator for the group of
service routers that are in the same redundancy group. Will make sure this
clarification is in the next Rev.
Thanks,
Sami
From: "Rabadan, Jorge (Nokia - US)"
Hi Sami,
Thank you.
I still fail to see this:
“The DF election between the service edge nodes will follow RFC 7432 using the
per ES Ethernet AD route, however will use the HRW algorithm.”
RFC7432’s DF election is purely based on the ES route and not the per ES AD
route. What do you mean with
sent to list as admin. message had bounced.
--- Begin Message ---
Hi Jorge,
Sorry for the delay, I will be addressing the comments below in the next rev,
and will be clarifying the DF election too.
The DF election between the service edge nodes will follow RFC 7432 using the
per ES Ethernet
sent to list as admin. message had bounced.
--- Begin Message ---
Sami,
I looked at your Service Edge Gateway draft, and since my comments/questions
were not addressed in rev 03, I’m resending our last exchange.
Besides the comments below (please see the thread from earlier this year), the
