Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-10 Thread UTTARO, JAMES
t>> Cc: "bess@ietf.org<mailto:bess@ietf.org>" mailto:bess@ietf.org>>, RTGWG mailto:rt...@ietf.org>>, Eric Rosen mailto:ero...@juniper.net>>, Robert Raszuk mailto:rob...@raszuk.net>>, Linda Dunbar mailto:linda.dun...@huawei.com>> Subject: RE:

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-10 Thread Jeff Tantsura
tf.org; RTGWG ; Eric Rosen ; Robert Raszuk ; Linda Dunbar Subject: Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01 There are also many companies using EVPN as the control plane. It is important to find a “golden middle” where on one side we achieve interoperability but on

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-10 Thread UTTARO, JAMES
] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01 There are also many companies using EVPN as the control plane. It is important to find a “golden middle” where on one side we achieve interoperability but on another don’t hinder the innovation in that, fast growing space. [Jim U>] Is t

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-06 Thread Jeff Tantsura
rt Raszuk > Cc: Ron Bonica ; RTGWG ; Eric Rosen > ; bess@ietf.org > Subject: RE: [bess] comments and suggestions to > draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01 > > Jess, > > Great Action! There are much more than the Data modeling. > A lot to be done in Control Plane. Many SD-WAN

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-06 Thread Ron Bonica
+1 Let’s follow up on this discussion in Montreal. From: Linda Dunbar Sent: Friday, July 6, 2018 4:33 PM To: Jeff Tantsura ; Robert Raszuk Cc: Ron Bonica ; RTGWG ; Eric Rosen ; bess@ietf.org Subject: RE: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01 Jess, Great Action

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-06 Thread Linda Dunbar
100s or 1000s CPEs. Linda From: BESS [mailto:bess-boun...@ietf.org] On Behalf Of Jeff Tantsura Sent: Friday, July 06, 2018 3:20 PM To: Robert Raszuk Cc: Ron Bonica ; RTGWG ; Eric Rosen ; bess@ietf.org; Linda Dunbar Subject: Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-06 Thread Jeff Tantsura
Robert/Linda, RTGWG chairs have been thinking of starting SD-WAN discussion in RTGWG. Service data modeling(data modeling in general)is an obvious candidate (at ONUG we started, there’s some early effort, but IETF help is needed). Control plane interworking is another interesting topic. Please br

Re: [bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-06 Thread Ron Bonica
Hi Linda, I'm not sure that I understand what you mean when you say, "aggregate CPE-based VPN routes with internet routes that interconnect the CPEs". Could you elaborate? Ron From: Linda Dunbar Sent: Thursday, July 5, 2018 11:53 AM

[bess] comments and suggestions to draft-rosen-bess-secure-l3vpn-01

2018-07-05 Thread Linda Dunbar
Eric and Ron, We think that the method described in your draft is useful for CPE based EVPN, especially for SD-WAN between CPEs. But, it misses some aspects to aggregate CPE-based VPN routes with internet routes that interconnect the CPEs. Question to you: Would you like to expand your draft to