Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-11-13 Thread Matthijs Mekking
Hi Nick, The timings are based on what is configured in the dnssec-policy: It is too costly to observe the zone every time to see if there is still a signature of the predecessor key. So yes: it takes the maximum possible time to determine when all signatures have been replaced. This time

Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-11-13 Thread Nick Tait via bind-users
On 03/10/2023 09:59, Eddie Rowe wrote: I appreciate the feedback.  I did make sure the ZSK is omnipresent and the issue still happens so it might be that my attempt to take the default policy and bring it down to 1 day to hurry along testing.  I will see if I can find any test policies in the

Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-10-02 Thread Eddie Rowe
the default one with a greater amount of patience. From: bind-users on behalf of Nick Tait via bind-users Sent: Friday, September 29, 2023 5:37 PM To: bind-users@lists.isc.org Subject: Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately Sorry I just realised that all

Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-09-29 Thread Nick Tait via bind-users
Sorry I just realised that all that waffle about DS records is only relevant for KSKs (and CSKs), not ZSKs. So please disregard that. :-P But I think the "rumoured" vs. "omnipresent" thing is still relevant and is the most likely explanation for why the old ZSK doesn't stick around. I can

Re: KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-09-29 Thread Nick Tait via bind-users
On 29/09/23 12:05, Eddie Rowe wrote: When I perform a ZSK key rollover the existing ZSK disappears *immediately* so not sure what I am missing when using the KASP to manage key rollover.  The state for the keys looks good and for this test I have TTL set to 1 hour..  But why does dig not show

KASP Key Rollover: ZSK Disappears Immediately

2023-09-28 Thread Eddie Rowe
When I perform a ZSK key rollover the existing ZSK disappears immediately so not sure what I am missing when using the KASP to manage key rollover. The state for the keys looks good and for this test I have TTL set to 1 hour.. But why does dig not show me both DNSKEY records for the ZSK after