Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Mark Andrews
In message <888060.89769...@web110304.mail.gq1.yahoo.com>, "prock...@yahoo.com" writes: > In a DNSSEC compliant world (I know we're not there yet) we need to give a co > py of our DSSET and KEYSET to our parent domain. Please confirm that is an a > ccurate statement. More correctly the parent n

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Paul Wouters
On Thu, 28 Jan 2010, prock...@yahoo.com wrote: So my question is, is there a way through DIG (or some other utility) to confirm that the parent domain has the DSSET and KEYSET records required to support the child domain? http://opensource.iis.se/trac/dnscheck/ $ dnscheck -test=dnssec xeler

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Chris Thompson
On Jan 28 2010, Joseph S D Yao wrote: On Thu, Jan 28, 2010 at 03:42:11PM +, Evan Hunt wrote: > Is there a tool/process to verify if the parenet domain has DSSET, > KEYSET, or keys in place for the child domain? Thanks. "dig ds ", and check that a) DS records are returned, and B) the firs

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Joseph S D Yao
On Thu, Jan 28, 2010 at 03:42:11PM +, Evan Hunt wrote: > > > Is there a tool/process to verify if the parenet domain has DSSET, > > KEYSET, or keys in place for the child domain? Thanks. > > "dig ds ", and check that a) DS records are returned, and > B) the first field of at least some of th

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Florian Weimer
* Chris Thompson: >>Parent zone policies vary. Some require DS RRs, some DNSKEY RRs. >>Demanding DNSKEY RRs can prolong the life of signature schemes with >>certain weaknesses (which might be helpful at some point in the >>future). > > I take it you refer there to the digest type field in the DS

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Chris Thompson
On Jan 28 2010, Florian Weimer wrote: * prock: In a DNSSEC compliant world (I know we're not there yet) we need to give a copy of our DSSET and KEYSET to our parent domain. Please confirm that is an accurate statement. Parent zone policies vary. Some require DS RRs, some DNSKEY RRs. Demand

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Michael Sinatra
On 01/28/10 07:57, prock...@yahoo.com wrote: That was very helpful. Thanks. One last query. For signed domains registered with and using ISC.ORG trust anchor, is there a sanity check similar to what you displayed below? If you mean ISC DLV registry, that service continually does sanity chec

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread prock...@yahoo.com
That was very helpful. Thanks. One last query. For signed domains registered with and using ISC.ORG trust anchor, is there a sanity check similar to what you displayed below? --- On Thu, 1/28/10, Evan Hunt wrote: > From: Evan Hunt > Subject: Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET > To: "prock...@yahoo.c

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Evan Hunt
> Is there a tool/process to verify if the parenet domain has DSSET, > KEYSET, or keys in place for the child domain? Thanks. "dig ds ", and check that a) DS records are returned, and B) the first field of at least some of the DS records match the key ID of the key-signing key for your zone. Fo

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Florian Weimer
* prock: > Is there a tool/process to verify if the parenet domain has DSSET, > KEYSET, or keys in place for the child domain? Thanks. No, such parent domain policies are not obvious from looking at the DNS. -- Florian Weimer BFK edv-consulting GmbH http://www.bfk.de/ Kri

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread prock...@yahoo.com
Is there a tool/process to verify if the parenet domain has DSSET, KEYSET, or keys in place for the child domain? Thanks. --- On Thu, 1/28/10, Florian Weimer wrote: > From: Florian Weimer > Subject: Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET > To: "prock...@yahoo.com" > Cc: bind-users@lists.isc.org > Date:

Re: DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread Florian Weimer
* prock: > In a DNSSEC compliant world (I know we're not there yet) we need to > give a copy of our DSSET and KEYSET to our parent domain. Please > confirm that is an accurate statement. Parent zone policies vary. Some require DS RRs, some DNSKEY RRs. Demanding DNSKEY RRs can prolong the life o

DNSSEC DSSET & KEYSET

2010-01-28 Thread prock...@yahoo.com
In a DNSSEC compliant world (I know we're not there yet) we need to give a copy of our DSSET and KEYSET to our parent domain. Please confirm that is an accurate statement. So my question is, is there a way through DIG (or some other utility) to confirm that the parent domain has the DSSET and