bind9.9.0rc1 DNSSEC key rollover failure

2012-01-08 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
A couple of weeks ago I found a DNSSEC key rollover problem with bind 9.9.0b2. See https://lists.isc.org/pipermail/bind-users/2011-December/086063.html. This appears to have persisted after upgrading to bind 9.9.0rc1 this afternoon. See http://dnsviz.net/d/jaspain.net/dnssec/. The RRSIGs on the

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-07-04 Thread /dev/rob0
On Fri, Jun 17, 2011 at 08:54:15PM +, Spain, Dr. Jeffry A. wrote: Tony Finch: What does `rndc sign zone` do? Thanks, Tony. I have never run rndc sign, as the zone is configured with auto-dnssec maintain. Before intervening in this manner, I would like to gain a greater understanding

RE: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-07-04 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
And now, as July 1 has passed and July 9 approaches, can you share a summary of what you found? Thanks. -- Offlist mail to this address is discarded unless /dev/rob0 or not-spam is in Subject: header On June 10, our zone countryday.net running on a bind 9.8.0 server began an

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-07-04 Thread Mark Andrews
In message 7610864823c0d04d89342623a3adc9de1b022...@hopple.countryday.net, Sp ain, Dr. Jeffry A. writes: And now, as July 1 has passed and July 9 approaches, can you share a summary of what you found? Thanks. -- Offlist mail to this address is discarded unless /dev/rob0 or

DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
For our zone countryday.net, which is configured with auto-dnssec maintain and is running on bind 9.8.0, a ZSK rollover is in progress but seems to be failing. The metadata for the original key is: ; This is a zone-signing key, keyid 2750, for countryday.net. ; Created: 20110402153620 (Sat Apr

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Tony Finch
Spain, Dr. Jeffry A. spa...@countryday.net wrote: I'm sure I could solve this by removing all of the DNSSEC data and resigning the zone, but would prefer not to do this except as a last resort. If anyone has troubleshooting suggestions or other insights, I would be grateful for those. Thanks.

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Phil Mayers
On 17/06/11 15:13, Spain, Dr. Jeffry A. wrote: As of today (6/17/2011), RRSIG records for key 2750 are present for every RRset in the zone. The only RRSIG record for key 33722 is for the SOA RRset. See http://dnsviz.net/d/countryday.net/dnssec/. As I understand the process, based on the dates

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Phil Mayers
On 06/17/2011 09:25 PM, Spain, Dr. Jeffry A. wrote: Our zone has 115 records, not counting DNSSEC-related records. I originally signed it by specifying the zone file and key directory along with auto-dnssec maintain in the configuration file. Looking at all the RRSIGs, they expire for the most

RE: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
Thanks, Phil. How big is the zone, and how did you sign it originally? If you used rndc sign, then there will be little jitter in the RRSIG so they'll all tend to roll over together. For most of our zones, I signed them manually using dnssec-signzone and tuning the jitter for a constant

RE: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
What does `rndc sign zone` do? Thanks, Tony. I have never run rndc sign, as the zone is configured with auto-dnssec maintain. Before intervening in this manner, I would like to gain a greater understanding of what is going on. Thanks. Jeff. ___

RE: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Spain, Dr. Jeffry A.
Thanks, Phil. The document I used to set up the rotation schedules is Good Practices Guide for Deploying DNSSEC at http://www.enisa.europa.eu/act/res/technologies/tech/gpgdnssec. It recommends a two-week interval between ZSK inactivation and deletion. I will carefully study the IETF draft

Re: DNSSEC key rollover failure

2011-06-17 Thread Mark Andrews
The only thing I would change is making the deletion happen sig-validity-interval after the inactivation of the key. The idea is to have a gradual replacement of signatures as they normally fall due for re-signing. Mark -- Mark Andrews, ISC 1 Seymour St., Dundas Valley, NSW 2117, Australia