Re: underscores in A queries

2021-04-09 Thread Ondřej Surý
Those are qname minimization queries. Because DNS implementations (especially in load-balancers) are so broken, the qname minimizing resolver can’t ask for: IN NS because that often doesn’t work, but when it asks: _. IN A the resolver will get the correct answer. Unfortunately, this is the

Re: underscores in A queries

2021-04-09 Thread Lee
On 4/9/21, John W. Blue via bind-users wrote: > It would seem that underscores is one of those characters in DNS that leads > a double life. > > RFC’s say that underscores are disallowed for use in hostnames Right. But it's **hostnames** and not everyone enforces that rule :( > but SRV >

RE: underscores in A queries

2021-04-09 Thread John W. Blue via bind-users
It would seem that underscores is one of those characters in DNS that leads a double life. RFC’s say that underscores are disallowed for use in hostnames but SRV records use it to indicate service type et al. And then you have the acm-validations.aws geniuses who use it their hostnames to