Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-28 Thread Juan Garavaglia via bitcoin-dev
otocol Discussion <bitcoin-dev@lists.linuxfoundation.org> Subject: Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners On 27/03/17 18:12, Btc Ideas via bitcoin-dev wrote: > Add a preference for mined blocks to be the one with more > transactions. This comes into play when 2 blocks

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-28 Thread Stian Ellingsen via bitcoin-dev
On 27/03/17 18:12, Btc Ideas via bitcoin-dev wrote: > Add a preference for mined blocks to be the one with more > transactions. This comes into play when 2 blocks of the same height > are found. The first good block mined would be orphaned if it had > less transactions than another. Optionally,

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-27 Thread Eric Voskuil via bitcoin-dev
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA256 On 03/27/2017 10:29 AM, Tom Zander via bitcoin-dev wrote: > For some time now the relation between block size and propagation > speed has been decoupled. Using xthin/compact blocks miners only > send a tiny version of a block which then causes the

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-27 Thread Tom Zander via bitcoin-dev
For some time now the relation between block size and propagation speed has been decoupled. Using xthin/compact blocks miners only send a tiny version of a block which then causes the receiving node to re-create it using the memory pool. Immediately getting double benefits by including

Re: [bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-27 Thread Jameson Lopp via bitcoin-dev
Bitcoin chooses the "best chain" based upon the one that has the most cumulative proof of work behind it. Are you proposing that the cumulative proof of work be ignored if two blocks are within a certain threshold of each others' work and if so, the number of transactions in the block / the size

[bitcoin-dev] Encouraging good miners

2017-03-27 Thread Btc Ideas via bitcoin-dev
Add a preference for mined blocks to be the one with more transactions. This comes into play when 2 blocks of the same height are found. The first good block mined would be orphaned if it had less transactions than another. Optionally, have this rule apply to the current block and the previous