Re: [bitcoin-dev] Use CPFP as consensus critical for Full-RBF

2015-11-29 Thread Jorge Timón via bitcoin-dev
Both CPFP and RBF are relay/mining policy and cannot be made consensus rules because you cannot know which transactions have been received by a givrn peer and which have not (or at what time). Consensus rules can only validate information that's in the blockchain. On Nov 29, 2015 5:33 AM, "Vincent

[bitcoin-dev] Use CPFP as consensus critical for Full-RBF

2015-11-28 Thread Vincent Truong via bitcoin-dev
(I haven't been following this development recently so apologies in advance if I've made assumptions about RBF) If you made CPFP consensus critical for all Full-RBF transactions, RBF should be safer to use. I see RBF as a necessity for users to fix mistakes (and not for transaction