Re: [Bitcoin-development] Combining big transactions with hash-only blocks to improve tps.

2014-01-22 Thread Christophe Biocca
Transactions are already sitting in everyone's (or nearly everyone's) mempools (because they get broadcast to get to a miner in the first place). If you don't have it (because you just connected to the network after stopping for a bit) you can just call getdata against your peers to get a copy. No

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Combining big transactions with hash-only blocks to improve tps.

2014-01-22 Thread bc
Jorge Timón: The node would need to first verify a block before mining on top of it. Basically a receiver would ask a sender for missing transactions if he doesn't know them already before propagating or mining the block. Christophe Biocca: You're right, my idea doesn't offer any real advantage o

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Combining big transactions with hash-only blocks to improve tps.

2014-01-22 Thread Jorge Timón
Maybe I'm missing something. How do miners validate blocks if they only receive the hashes of the transactions? Will they mine on top of a block when they don't know if it's valid? On 1/22/14, Christophe Biocca wrote: > Comments: > > bc: > - Ultimately, this helps with block propagation latency,

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Combining big transactions with hash-only blocks to improve tps.

2014-01-22 Thread Christophe Biocca
Comments: bc: - Ultimately, this helps with block propagation latency, but not with the bandwidth constraints themselves, because all transactions do need to be broadcast. - Most of the benefits of your approach can be obtained simply by prebroadcasting the entire merkle tree while you're working

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Combining big transactions with hash-only blocks to improve tps.

2014-01-22 Thread Natanael
Couldn't we also use the type of zkSNARK's that Zerocoin adopted to prove that the hash-only blocks only have valid transactions in it, since they are small and quite efficient to verify? The trouble is that they're still inefficient to generate, but given powerful enough computers that compiles th