[boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Bernd Machenschalk
Hi! We just stumbled upon a major problem with the app selection mechanism in BOINC: - when a user edits his project preferences to e.g. opt-out of an application, all applications that he wants to run and that are known AT THAT TIME are added to the project preferences - when a new

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Peter Slacik
Few (or many?) of projects, which allow to selectively opt-in/out for each single applications, have one more optional checkbox to automatically opt-in for each new application, which will be added by the project at some later time for a particular venue. This way the user is guaranteed to get

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Bernd Machenschalk
On 03.11.11 13:24, Peter Slacik wrote: Few (or many?) of projects, which allow to selectively opt-in/out for each single applications, have one more optional checkbox to automatically opt-in for each new application, which will be added by the project at some later time for a particular

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Bernd Machenschalk
On 03.11.11 16:15, Peter Slacik wrote: OK, my apology, you've got me. The majority of the projects actually tell something different from what I wrote, e.g.: PrimeGrid project prefs (http://www.primegrid.com/prefs.php?subset=projectcols=0

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread John . McLeod
Yes, it means one that you have explicitly opted out of and all new applications as they become available. It would be nice to have two different settings. One to allow applications that I have opted out of if there is nothing else to do, and another for applications yet to be listed. It would

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Jon Sonntag
If I choose to run only certain apps for a project and I choose not to accept work from other apps when those apps cannot get work, I would be very unhappy if the project ignored my preferences and decided I should run some new app without my approval. I chose those preferences for a reason. If

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread John . McLeod
No. The suggestion is to have another checkbox Opt in to all new applications. If that were unchecked, then you would have to add all new applications that you wanted to run by hand. If it were checked, you would be opted in to all new applications, and would have to go unselect the ones that

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread David Anderson
I agree. Let's keep things the way they are. -- David On 03-Nov-2011 9:55 AM, Jon Sonntag wrote: If I choose to run only certain apps for a project and I choose not to accept work from other apps when those apps cannot get work, I would be very unhappy if the project ignored my preferences and

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread David Anderson
This checkbox, AFAIK, is not part of the BOINC source code. -- David On 03-Nov-2011 5:24 AM, Peter Slacik wrote: Few (or many?) of projects, which allow to selectively opt-in/out for each single applications, have one more optional checkbox to automatically opt-in for each new application,

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread David Anderson
On 03-Nov-2011 9:20 AM, john.mcl...@sybase.com wrote: It would also be nice to link the applications listed in the applications list with the applications listed for selection so that the administrator did not have to create the list in two places. (apparently they do have to create the

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Bernd Machenschalk
I know, but a checkbox is easy to add. Is there any support in BOINC (sched_send etc.) for this behavior? Bernd David Anderson da...@ssl.berkeley.edu schrieb: This checkbox, AFAIK, is not part of the BOINC source code. -- David On 03-Nov-2011 5:24 AM, Peter Slacik wrote: Few (or many?) of

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread David Anderson
On 03-Nov-2011 12:03 PM, Bernd Machenschalk wrote: I know, but a checkbox is easy to add. Is there any support in BOINC (sched_send etc.) for this behavior? No. ___ boinc_dev mailing list boinc_dev@ssl.berkeley.edu

[boinc_dev] Israel Figueroa has invited you to use Google Talk

2011-11-03 Thread Israel Figueroa
Israel Figueroa has invited you to sign up for Google Talk so you can talk to each other for free over your computers. To sign-up, go to:

[boinc_dev] Couple of Questions

2011-11-03 Thread Israel Figueroa
Hello, I did my homework, but this two things seems to elude me. 1) When the client it's a multicore (core2duo, QuadCore or GPU/CPU), how the p_iops and p_fops information should be interpreted? as per core (asuming that the total host it's ncpus * p_iops ) or the number of cores it's integrated

Re: [boinc_dev] app selection problem

2011-11-03 Thread Bernd Machenschalk
It looks ok to me to be a preference setting. What I am more concerned about are contributors that attached to the project once, edited their preferences to opt out an App they had problems with, and then forgot. They even run Clients too old to support notices. Bernd Jon Sonntag