Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-06-03 Thread David Larochelle
Jerrad, Thanks for pointing me to these projects. Unfortunately Algorithm::CRFhttp://search.cpan.org/~clsung/Algorithm-CRF-0.04/lib/Algorithm/CRF.pm, was last updated in 2006. I haven't tested it but it appears to be alpha quality based on the fact that it has stub documentation. Also it provides

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread David Larochelle
Thanks William, My biggest concern with Inline::Java is why it isn't more widely known and used. For data analysis, there are two main choices: Python and the JVM stack. CPAN is nice but it just doesn't have the data libraries these platforms do. It would seem like Inline::Java would be

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread Jerrad Pierce
For general data analysis, PDL, Statistics::R or PDL::R::math seem like more logical choices than the languages you mentioned. ___ Boston-pm mailing list Boston-pm@mail.pm.org http://mail.pm.org/mailman/listinfo/boston-pm

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread Gyepi SAM
On Wed, May 29, 2013 at 01:41:56PM -0400, David Larochelle wrote: My biggest concern with Inline::Java is why it isn't more widely known and used. I would not read too much into the fact that a particular solution is not popular. I have used, and continue to use, such tools when appropriate.

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread William Cox
My suspicion is that it's 2-fold: 1. Java doesn't fit the Perl mold 2. Inline::Java can be tricky to get setup (despite the docs appearing to make it easy) On (1), the development philosophies between perl and java tend to be so different that each side almost writes the other off. In my

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread David Larochelle
Jerrad, I haven't used Statistics::R but it's probably worth considering. I suppose that R also merited mention as a language for data analysis in addition to Python and Java/JVM. With regard to PDL, for most tasks you want be be able to easily apply a known algorithm to your data and not have

Re: [Boston.pm] Inline::Java

2013-05-29 Thread David Larochelle
William, Thank you for offering your thoughts and your experiences. I feel about better about using Inline::Java. My application is large enough that porting it to another language would be nontrivial. Inline::Java seem like a better choice than the alternatives such as calling Java with system,