RE: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-30 Thread Horn, John
From: John D. Giorgis [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] By the way - of the recent developments in the nuclear programs of the DPRK, India, Pakistan, Iran, and Iraq over the past 15 years - how many occurred with the knowledge of US intelligence sources? I'll give you a hint - the answer is

RE: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-28 Thread Ritu
John D. Giorgis wrote: As for your argument that liberation of Afghanistan would not have been justified on September 10th, 2001 - well I find it most peculiar to hear the logic of retribution coming from you.The liberation of Afghanistan was justified because it made the Afghan

Re: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread Michael Harney
From: John D. Giorgis [EMAIL PROTECTED] At 03:14 PM 7/27/2003 -0600 Michael Harney wrote: The war on Iraq wasn't about liberating Iraq, it wasn't about weapons of mass destruction or terrorism. It was entirely politically motivated. The republicans saw their approval failing after Osama

Re: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread Gautam Mukunda
--- John D. Giorgis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm glad you brought this up, Michael, because the answer is between 100,000 and 200,000.Meanwhile, according to UNICEF, Saddam Hussein was kiilling around 5,000 people a day. Of course, the Left only cares about people killed by

Re: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread John D. Giorgis
At 06:24 PM 7/27/2003 -0700 Gautam Mukunda wrote: --- John D. Giorgis [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I'm glad you brought this up, Michael, because the answer is between 100,000 and 200,000.Meanwhile, according to UNICEF, Saddam Hussein was kiilling around 5,000 people a day. Of course,

RE: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread Jon Gabriel
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of John D. Giorgis Sent: Sunday, July 27, 2003 7:31 PM To: Killer Bs Discussion Subject: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words big snip Your suggestion that the left's inability to form an effective war plan

RE: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread Jon Gabriel
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of John D. Giorgis Sent: Sunday, July 27, 2003 10:50 PM To: Killer Bs Discussion Subject: Re: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words At 06:24 PM 7/27/2003 -0700 Gautam Mukunda wrote: --- John D. Giorgis [EMAIL

Re: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread John D. Giorgis
Michael, The NY Times reports that the US was considering Iraq as early as 9/13/01. You seem to somehow imagine that Bush including Iraq in the axis of evil in January somehow was not a clear signal that the US intended to effect regime change in Iraq. Yet, by Presidents Day 2002, again while

RE: Justifying the War Re: Seth Finkelstein on 16 words

2003-07-27 Thread John D. Giorgis
At 11:26 PM 7/27/2003 -0400 Jon Gabriel wrote: Didn't the Iraqi Information Minister say that the total number of casualties was 100,000? Hilarious! Should we expect your next 'unimpeachable' source to be the Jon Lovitz' Tommy the Liar character from SNL? If nothing else, I figured that