RE: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-14 Thread Horn, John
From: Gary Denton [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Being stupid doesn't get a criminal out of being prosecuted for his crimes, why should it in this case? It's intent that counts, isn't it? I forget if it was Wolfowitz or Perle who thought he shouldn't be

Re: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-14 Thread Gary Denton
On Mon, 14 Jun 2004 17:52:28 -0500, Horn, John [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Gary Denton [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Being stupid doesn't get a criminal out of being prosecuted for his crimes, why should it in this case? It's intent that counts, isn't

Re: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-14 Thread Doug Pensinger
John Horn wrote: I agree with that but it is a completely different issue. If someone was planning on blowing up the Lincoln Memorial with a pack of playing cards they would still be liable to be prosecuted with that even if it is completely impossible, right? I see your point, but would the

Re: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-14 Thread Ronn!Blankenship
At 08:11 PM 6/14/04 -0500, Gary Denton wrote: Actually, I don't think so. If I pulled out my banana and said I was going to vaporize you with it I would not be charged with murder. I dunno. I was in a movie some years back where I used a banana¹ as a lethal weapon. _ ¹Several bananas

RE: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-10 Thread Horn, John
From: Robert Seeberger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] The Justice Department didn't respond directly when asked this week whether it had consulted with experts and knew that uranium wouldn't make a dirty bomb. Instead, spokesman Mark Corallo said Padilla's statements, in view of his al-Qaida

Re: Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-10 Thread Gary Denton
On Thu, 10 Jun 2004 11:00:56 -0500, Horn, John [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Robert Seeberger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] The Justice Department didn't respond directly when asked this week whether it had consulted with experts and knew that uranium wouldn't make a dirty bomb.

Dirty Bomb Would Be a Dud

2004-06-09 Thread Robert Seeberger
http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=storyu=/ap/20040609/ap_on_sc/dirty_bomb_dud http://tinyurl.com/2kjku The dirty bomb allegedly planned by terror suspect Jose Padilla would have been a dud, not the radiological threat portrayed last week by federal authorities, scientists say. At a June 1 news