Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-10 Thread tshipley
- From: Matt Grimaldi matzeb...@yahoo.com Date: Fri, 7 Aug 2009 17:22:29 To: Killer Bs \(David Brin et al\) Discussionbrin-l@mccmedia.com Subject: Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood. That falls in with IAAMOAC. There are dues to pay when you

Re: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-10 Thread Trent Shipley
Dan M wrote: Of course, I knew there was another strain in libertarianism that was based in morality. This was an ideological commitment to maximize individual freedom. Basically Aleister Crowley's Harm no one and do what thou wilt, with the harm no one clause being

Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-07 Thread Nick Arnett
On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 7:42 PM, Trent Shipley tship...@deru.com wrote: It started me thinking about the bases of libertarianism and American conservatism. Previously when I had thought of libertarianism, I had not thought of it as particularly based in a moral principle. Good for you...

Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-07 Thread Trent Shipley
While writing this I tried to imagine how a certain kind of libertarian thought about the world. It is a shallow exercise in participant observation. To appreciate what I wrote you must at least partially empathize with our libertarian subject. Nick Arnett wrote: On Thu, Aug 6, 2009 at 7:42

Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-07 Thread David Hobby
Trent Shipley wrote: ... The moral principle that taxes are theft suffers from a similar limitation. Logically taxes ARE theft. Newspeak! I stand behind this. When theft is understood as any taking, except as punishment, then taxes are logically a form of theft. It's a logical

Re: Br!n: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-07 Thread Matt Grimaldi
--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood. Trent Shipley wrote: ... The moral principle that taxes are theft suffers from a similar limitation. Logically taxes ARE theft. Newspeak! I stand behind this. When theft is understood as any taking, except as punishment

RE: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-07 Thread Dan M
  Of course, I knew there was another strain in libertarianism that was based in morality.  This was an ideological commitment to maximize individual freedom.  Basically Aleister Crowley's Harm no one and do what thou wilt, with the harm no one clause being optional--particularly when doing

Brin: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread Trent Shipley
I wrote a suggestion to my Arizona State legislators about de-funding the state universities in favor of tuition vouchers. Vouchers would be in keeping with Arizona's conservative libertarian bias in favor of a low taxes-low wages-strong small business environment. If I lived in Massachusetts or

Re: Brin: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread David Hobby
Trent Shipley wrote: I wrote a suggestion to my Arizona State legislators about de-funding the state universities in favor of tuition vouchers. ... Dear Senator Linda Gray, Representative Doug Quelland, and Representative Jim Weiers, ... “Be it resolved that the mission of Arizona's public

Re: Brin: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread Trent Shipley
David Hobby wrote: Trent Shipley wrote: I wrote a suggestion to my Arizona State legislators about de-funding the state universities in favor of tuition vouchers. ... Dear Senator Linda Gray, Representative Doug Quelland, and Representative Jim Weiers, ... “Be it resolved that the

Re: Brin: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread David Hobby
Trent Shipley wrote: Hi. It's interesting. I wonder about the last bit, though. How does one tell whether or not a profession is essential? (I can certainly name some that I feel are NOT essential, but let's get beyond our personal biases.) One answer may be a profession is essential

Re: [Brin]: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread Trent Shipley
David Hobby wrote: Trent Shipley wrote: Hi. It's interesting. I wonder about the last bit, though. How does one tell whether or not a profession is essential? (I can certainly name some that I feel are NOT essential, but let's get beyond our personal biases.) One answer may be a

Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood.

2009-08-06 Thread David Brin
from this thread. And thrive all. db From: Trent Shipley tship...@deru.com To: brin-l@mccmedia.com Sent: Thursday, August 6, 2009 7:42:49 PM Subject: Brin: Libertarian Morality--Up with good King John, down with Robin Hood. I wrote a suggestion to my Arizona