Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-16 Thread David Hedlund
Vote here: https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?49616 (updated) On 2016-11-16 11:46, Narcis Garcia wrote: I believe that Icecat should have same derivative modifications as TorWebbrowser, and then TorWebbrowser should use Icecat's code base. El 14/11/16 a les 20:04, Daniel Quintiliani ha escrit:

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-16 Thread Narcis Garcia
I believe that Icecat should have same derivative modifications as TorWebbrowser, and then TorWebbrowser should use Icecat's code base. El 14/11/16 a les 20:04, Daniel Quintiliani ha escrit: > Should we use the Tor code as a basis for Icecat? > > 1. Yes > 2. No > > I vote #1 > > -- > > -Dan

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-15 Thread bch
Hello all I'm not 'voting' as I do not fully understand what is going on to cause all the debate and argument. I started using Icecat as I felt I had a noticeable performance improvement over the over offerings. Since then it has not updated much and appears to be well behind the Firefox base at

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-15 Thread ng0
ng0 writes: > "Daniel Quintiliani" writes: > >> Should we use the Tor code as a basis for Icecat? >> >> 1. Yes >> 2. No >> >> I vote #1 > > Assuming that you mean torbrowser code, where most of it is being > upstreamed anyway, I vote #1 I change my

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-14 Thread Gary
I don't know about the Windows and macOS ports but the Linux version of Icecat could be derived from the Trisquel abrowser source if they are kind enough to allow and encourage us to do so. My comments here should in no way be considered a judgement of either of these ambitious and much needed

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-14 Thread Mart Rootamm
Voting against: #2 and No, that is — per arguments by Gary Driggs. Additional voting is here: https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/index.php?49604 The Tor Browser is its own thing, and its code base seems to have diverged, though most of it is based on upstream Firefox ESR. If IceCat were based on Tor

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-14 Thread Gary Driggs
I see this project having more in common with the Trisquel browser project than TOR browser. I haven't seen anyone list the pros or cons so I'll have to vote against if it's just arbitrary. -- http://gnuzilla.gnu.org

Re: [Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-14 Thread ng0
"Daniel Quintiliani" writes: > Should we use the Tor code as a basis for Icecat? > > 1. Yes > 2. No > > I vote #1 Assuming that you mean torbrowser code, where most of it is being upstreamed anyway, I vote #1 -- http://gnuzilla.gnu.org

[Bug-gnuzilla] [VOTE] Tor code base

2016-11-14 Thread Daniel Quintiliani
Should we use the Tor code as a basis for Icecat? 1. Yes 2. No I vote #1 -- -Dan Q -- http://gnuzilla.gnu.org