Re: suggestion: new make function

2011-09-25 Thread Luke Shumaker
At Tue, 20 Sep 2011 12:09:42 -0700, Lawrence Ibarria wrote: I have often hit problems with the limit of command line lengths many shells have (CMD.EXE in Windows in my case). This is a common case with few solutions, I have searched around: http://www.makelinux.net/make3/make3-CHP-5-SECT-6

Fwd: Re: suggestion: new make function

2011-09-25 Thread Luke Shumaker
You didn't CC the list ---BeginMessage--- I use the foreach trick and it utterly sucks. It's complicated and tends to execute the shell 10x more than it needs to. For small makefiles it doesn't matter but doing this for compiles (e.g. the ARM RVCT's multifile compilation option) in a large

Re: suggestion: new make function

2011-09-25 Thread Luke Shumaker
At Sun, 25 Sep 2011 19:36:26 +0100, Tim Murphy wrote: My apologies to Luke for forgetting reply to all and for forgetting my manners by using the word sucks when I should not have. Now it's my turn to apologize, I just forwarded your original message to me to the list. Sorry. dumpOneLine =

Re: suggestion: new make function

2011-09-25 Thread Norbert Thiebaud
I find your suggestions more elagant than the original, they seem more general purpose, and less let's introduce this feature to get around a specific problem. Of your two suggestions, I'd favor the withfile option, it would be both more powerful, and doesn't introduce the problem of trying