Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-07-28 Thread Markus Steinborn
I have rebased my patches to GNU tar 1.28 - clone the git repository git://gitorious.org/tar-fcaps/tar-fcaps.git to access them and look in the branch pu (ACL patches) and pu2 (Capabilities patch). If you wonder: I am using the version in branch "msteinborn-1.28". Greetings from Germany Mark

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-07-16 Thread Markus Steinborn
I've still no decision about the following - let me add one note to it: Patch 2 of the series contained a bug - take the attached file as a replacement. Markus Steinborn wrote: What about the following patches? Markus Steinborn wrote Hi, I'd like to remember of the following bug report a

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-02-15 Thread Markus Steinborn
Sergey Poznyakoff schrieb: Yes, they are next in my queue. That are great news. IMHO tweaking the xattr-related options would be good. The portablity problems even between different linux kernel versions of File capatibilies lead me to the point that I'd like to archive only user.* xattrs,

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-02-15 Thread Sergey Poznyakoff
Hi Markus, > What about the following patches? Yes, they are next in my queue. Regards, Sergey

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-02-14 Thread Markus Steinborn
What about the following patches? Markus Steinborn wrote Hi, I'd like to remember of the following bug report and to announce that I have finished patches for all these issues. I have submitted my patches to redhat (as they currently apply clean on a redhat patched tar 1.27.1). See https:/

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-01-14 Thread Markus Steinborn
Hi Pavel, Pavel Raiskup wrote: Still, even as a Fedora/RHEL (co)maintainer I would prefer making the patches pass against GNU git master. It makes things more easy for GNU tar upstream and it is not problem for me to backport such patches to Fedora. I see. This has come from the following fact:

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-01-14 Thread Pavel Raiskup
> I'd like to remember of the following bug report and to announce that I > have finished patches for all these issues. Marcus, thanks for looking at this problem. I think fixes for ACLs/capabilities are really important, though I have not looked at your code yet. > I have submitted my patches t

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2014-01-14 Thread Markus Steinborn
Hi, I'd like to remember of the following bug report and to announce that I have finished patches for all these issues. I have submitted my patches to redhat (as they currently apply clean on a redhat patched tar 1.27.1). See https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1052876 for them. If

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-10-06 Thread Joerg Schilling
Markus Steinborn wrote: > >> star stores the numeric owner in a forth field of an acl: (e.g. > >> "u:msteinbo:rwx:500"). > > Correct, this is an extension to the ACL format that was needed to allow > > ACLs > > to be archivable in a reliable way at all. > > > Well, I have to notice that this is

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-10-06 Thread Markus Steinborn
Joerg Schilling schrieb: Markus Steinborn wrote: (2a) tar archive creation without "--numeric-owner" option: In GNU tar 1.26, for every file the owner is stored both, symbolic and numeric. I would expect that ACLs are stored in both ways, too. star shows us how to do that: star stores the nu

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-09-16 Thread Markus Steinborn
Hi, given that I've read in this mailing list that a release is planed, I'm poiting you to the following: I suggest fixing it before release. Markus Steinborn schrieb: Hi, I'd like to remind the maintainers of GNU tar to the following post to bug-tar: Markus Steinborn schrieb: Hi ever

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-04-26 Thread Paul Eggert
That sort of thing all sounds reasonable, I guess. I'd like Sergey's opinion though.

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-04-26 Thread Markus Steinborn
Hi, I'd like to remind the maintainers of GNU tar to the following post to bug-tar: Markus Steinborn schrieb: Hi everybody, Today I noticed that GNU tar (git master) now supports XATTRs, ACLs and SELINUX-Attributes. I am really pleased to read this in "git log". Congratualtions for this im

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Joerg Schilling
Markus Steinborn wrote: > Joerg Schilling schrieb: > > With "normal" user credentials in tar, this works, as you may just omit the > > user/group name fields in the tar header. > > > > With ACL fields, you cannot do that as star uses a ACL description that was > > derived from an outdated stannda

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Markus Steinborn
Joerg Schilling schrieb: With "normal" user credentials in tar, this works, as you may just omit the user/group name fields in the tar header. With ACL fields, you cannot do that as star uses a ACL description that was derived from an outdated stanndard proposal. I've tested this some time ago:

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Joerg Schilling
Markus Steinborn wrote: > >> (1) tar archive creation with "--numeric-owner" option: > >> > >> In this case, users are expectiing that the archive does not contain any > >> symbolic owner name, so it can be extracted to an emoty hard disc on a > >> system bootet e. g. by a rescue cd from Redhat.

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Markus Steinborn
Joerg Schilling schrieb: star stores the numeric owner in a forth field of an acl: (e.g. "u:msteinbo:rwx:500"). Correct, this is an extension to the ACL format that was needed to allow ACLs to be archivable in a reliable way at all. Fine that you agree that GNU gv should support that. (2b) tar

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Markus Steinborn
Joerg Schilling schrieb: Markus Steinborn wrote: Hi everybody, Today I noticed that GNU tar (git master) now supports XATTRs, ACLs and SELINUX-Attributes. I am really pleased to read this in "git log". Congratualtions for this improvement. The improvements do not break star und redhat tar com

Re: [Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-18 Thread Joerg Schilling
Markus Steinborn wrote: > Hi everybody, > > Today I noticed that GNU tar (git master) now supports XATTRs, ACLs and > SELINUX-Attributes. I am really pleased to read this in "git log". > Congratualtions for this improvement. The improvements do not break star > und redhat tar compatibility. >

[Bug-tar] ACL support in git version of GNU tar

2013-03-17 Thread Markus Steinborn
Hi everybody, Today I noticed that GNU tar (git master) now supports XATTRs, ACLs and SELINUX-Attributes. I am really pleased to read this in "git log". Congratualtions for this improvement. The improvements do not break star und redhat tar compatibility. Having used Redhats patch for many y