Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
On Fri, Nov 24, 2023 at 03:57:04PM +, Stefan Sperling wrote: > > Anyway, the best way to figure out which firmware is needed is to run > a version of the Linux driver that supports your device. > If your Linux distro is not bleeding-edge enough, try building the driver > from the backport-iwlwifi repository which is generally newer than mainline > Linux: > https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/iwlwifi/backport-iwlwifi.git/ > I have the same hardware and I got this device working with a small change that I posted in https://marc.info/?l=openbsd-tech=170387720918314=2
Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
On Thu, Nov 23, 2023 at 08:26:32PM +, Stuart Henderson wrote:
> On 2023/11/23 19:38, Stefan Sperling wrote:
> > It is possible that our driver is trying to use an incompatible
> > firmware image on this particular device. Which firmware file name
> > is loaded by the iwlwifi driver on a recent Linux distribution?
> > Are we loading the same one?
>
> Seems the first liveusb image that I picked up (Debian 12.2.0) isn't
> bleeding edge enough. Apparently it is actually an AX101.
Unfortunately, product names like AX101 don't mean anything in terms of
mapping a firmware image to a device. This is the collection of variables
used in the device lookup table:
struct iwx_dev_info {
uint16_t device;
uint16_t subdevice;
uint16_t mac_type;
uint16_t rf_type;
uint8_t mac_step;
uint8_t rf_id;
uint8_t no_160;
uint8_t cores;
uint8_t cdb;
uint8_t jacket;
const struct iwx_device_cfg *cfg;
};
Given all this info, a partial or complete match will eventually
result in a decision about which firmware image to load.
I suppose you can now see why it is easy to miscategorize a device
by accident. I don't know why Intel is doing it this way. Perhaps
they are running out of PCI product IDs.
Anyway, the best way to figure out which firmware is needed is to run
a version of the Linux driver that supports your device.
If your Linux distro is not bleeding-edge enough, try building the driver
from the backport-iwlwifi repository which is generally newer than mainline
Linux:
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/iwlwifi/backport-iwlwifi.git/
If the device is very new it is possible that further driver-side changes
will be required to get it to work.
Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
On 2023/11/23 19:38, Stefan Sperling wrote: > It is possible that our driver is trying to use an incompatible > firmware image on this particular device. Which firmware file name > is loaded by the iwlwifi driver on a recent Linux distribution? > Are we loading the same one? Seems the first liveusb image that I picked up (Debian 12.2.0) isn't bleeding edge enough. Apparently it is actually an AX101.
Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
On Thu, Nov 23, 2023 at 12:46:24PM +, Stuart Henderson wrote: > and here are kernel messages with IWX_DEBUG defined > > iwx0: L1 Disabled - LTR Enabled > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 0 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 1 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 2 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 3 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 4 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 5 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 6 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 7 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 8 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 9 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 10 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 11 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 12 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 13 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 14 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 15 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 16 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 17 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 18 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 19 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 20 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 21 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 22 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 23 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 24 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 25 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 26 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 27 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 28 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 29 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 30 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 31 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 32 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 33 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 34 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 35 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 36 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 37 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 38 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 39 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 40 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 41 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 42 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 43 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 44 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 45 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 46 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 47 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 48 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 49 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 50 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 51 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 52 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 53 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 54 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 55 > iwx0: ucode type 0 section 56 > iwx0: L1 Disabled - LTR Enabled > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 0 at 0x40335000 size 1656 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 1 at 0x40777000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 2 at 0x4077f000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 3 at 0x40787000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 4 at 0x4078f000 size 32760 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 5 at 0x40797000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 6 at 0x4079f000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 7 at 0x407a7000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 8 at 0x407af000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 9 at 0x407b7000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 10 at 0x407bf000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 11 at 0x407c7000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 12 at 0x407cf000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 13 at 0x40334000 size 560 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 14 at 0x407d7000 size 21696 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 0 at 0x40333000 size 1656 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 1 at 0x407dd000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 2 at 0x407e5000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 3 at 0x407ed000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 4 at 0x407f5000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 5 at 0x407fd000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 6 at 0x40805000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 7 at 0x4080d000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 8 at 0x40815000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 9 at 0x4081d000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 10 at 0x40825000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 11 at 0x4082d000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 12 at 0x40835000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 13 at 0x4083d000 size 14408 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 14 at 0x40841000 size 4616 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 15 at 0x40843000 size 24756 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 0 at 0x40332000 size 1656 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 1 at 0x4084a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 2 at 0x40852000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 3 at 0x4085a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 4 at 0x40862000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 5 at 0x4086a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 6 at 0x40872000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 7 at 0x4087a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 8 at 0x40882000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 9 at 0x4088a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 10 at 0x40892000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 11 at 0x4089a000 size 32768 > iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging
Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
and here are kernel messages with IWX_DEBUG defined iwx0: L1 Disabled - LTR Enabled iwx0: ucode type 0 section 0 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 1 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 2 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 3 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 4 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 5 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 6 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 7 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 8 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 9 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 10 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 11 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 12 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 13 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 14 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 15 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 16 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 17 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 18 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 19 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 20 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 21 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 22 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 23 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 24 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 25 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 26 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 27 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 28 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 29 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 30 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 31 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 32 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 33 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 34 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 35 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 36 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 37 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 38 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 39 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 40 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 41 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 42 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 43 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 44 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 45 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 46 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 47 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 48 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 49 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 50 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 51 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 52 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 53 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 54 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 55 iwx0: ucode type 0 section 56 iwx0: L1 Disabled - LTR Enabled iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 0 at 0x40335000 size 1656 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 1 at 0x40777000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 2 at 0x4077f000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 3 at 0x40787000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 4 at 0x4078f000 size 32760 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 5 at 0x40797000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 6 at 0x4079f000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 7 at 0x407a7000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 8 at 0x407af000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 9 at 0x407b7000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 10 at 0x407bf000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 11 at 0x407c7000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 12 at 0x407cf000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 13 at 0x40334000 size 560 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware LMAC section 14 at 0x407d7000 size 21696 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 0 at 0x40333000 size 1656 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 1 at 0x407dd000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 2 at 0x407e5000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 3 at 0x407ed000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 4 at 0x407f5000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 5 at 0x407fd000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 6 at 0x40805000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 7 at 0x4080d000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 8 at 0x40815000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 9 at 0x4081d000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 10 at 0x40825000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 11 at 0x4082d000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 12 at 0x40835000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 13 at 0x4083d000 size 14408 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 14 at 0x40841000 size 4616 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware UMAC section 15 at 0x40843000 size 24756 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 0 at 0x40332000 size 1656 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 1 at 0x4084a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 2 at 0x40852000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 3 at 0x4085a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 4 at 0x40862000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 5 at 0x4086a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 6 at 0x40872000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 7 at 0x4087a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 8 at 0x40882000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 9 at 0x4088a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 10 at 0x40892000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 11 at 0x4089a000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 12 at 0x408a2000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 13 at 0x408aa000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 14 at 0x408b2000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging section 15 at 0x408ba000 size 32768 iwx_init_fw_sec: firmware paging
Re: AX211 wifi firmware load issue
On Thu, Nov 23, 2023 at 11:20:27AM +, Stuart Henderson wrote:
> On 2023/11/22 19:37, Gireesh wrote:
> > blinkopenbsd$ dmesg | grep iwx0
> > iwx0 at pci0 dev 20 function 3 "Intel Wi-Fi 6 AX211" rev 0x00, msix
> > iwx0: could not load firmware, 35
> > iwx0: failed to load init firmware
> >
> > pcidump -v
> >
> > 0:20:3: Intel Wi-Fi 6 AX211
> [..snip..]
> > 0x0164: Enhanced Capability 0x0b: Vendor-Specific
> > 0x0080: Capability 0x11: Extended Message Signalled Interrupts (MSI-X)
> > Enabled: yes; table size 16 (BAR 0:8192)
> >
> > Computer in question
> >
> > https://www.amazon.com/Beelink-Desktop-Computer-Support-Ethernet/dp/B0BVLS7ZHP
>
> You really should include all the information when reporting a problem
> rather than just the bits which you think might be useful.
>
> As luck would have it, I have one of those machines. Here's a real dmesg
> and full pcidump/acpidump as generated by sendbug -P.
Diff to add and match on some of those. Based on tables in:
Intel Processor and Intel Core i3 N-Series
Datasheet, Volume 1 of 2, Doc. No.: 759603, Rev.: 001
Index: sys/dev/pci/pcidevs
===
RCS file: /cvs/src/sys/dev/pci/pcidevs,v
diff -u -p -r1.2054 pcidevs
--- sys/dev/pci/pcidevs 23 Nov 2023 05:08:56 - 1.2054
+++ sys/dev/pci/pcidevs 23 Nov 2023 12:38:17 -
@@ -5602,8 +5602,11 @@ product INTEL ADL_U9_HB_20x460a Core 12
product INTEL ADL_S_PCIE_1 0x460d Core 12G PCIE
product INTEL ADL_XDCI 0x460e Core 12G xDCI
product INTEL ADL_S_HB_6 0x4610 Core 12G Host
+product INTEL ADL_N_HB_1 0x4617 ADL-N Host
product INTEL ADL_U15_HB_2 0x4619 Core 12G Host
product INTEL ADL_U9_HB_3 0x461a Core 12G Host
+product INTEL ADL_N_HB_2 0x461b N200 Host
+product INTEL ADL_N_HB_3 0x461c N100 Host
product INTEL ADL_S_DTT0x461d Core 12G DTT
product INTEL ADL_XHCI 0x461e Core 12G xHCI
product INTEL ADL_TBT_PCIE30x461f Core 12G PCIE
@@ -5896,7 +5899,48 @@ product INTEL 600SERIES_LP_ISH 0x51fc 60
product INTEL 600SERIES_LP_UFS 0x51ff 600 Series UFS
product INTEL 80960RD 0x5200 i960 RD
product INTEL PRO_100_SERVER 0x5201 PRO 100 Server
+product INTEL ADL_N_ESPI 0x5481 ADL-N eSPI
+product INTEL ADL_N_P2SB 0x54a0 ADL-N P2SB
+product INTEL ADL_N_PMC0x54a1 ADL-N PMC
+product INTEL ADL_N_SMB0x54a3 ADL-N SMBus
+product INTEL ADL_N_SPI0x54a4 ADL-N SPI
+product INTEL ADL_N_TH 0x54a6 ADL-N TH
+product INTEL ADL_N_UART_0 0x54a8 ADL-N UART
+product INTEL ADL_N_UART_1 0x54a9 ADL-N UART
+product INTEL ADL_N_GSPI_0 0x54aa ADL-N GSPI
+product INTEL ADL_N_GSPI_1 0x54ab ADL-N GSPI
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_9 0x54b0 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_100x54b1 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_110x54b2 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_120x54b3 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_1 0x54b8 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_2 0x54b9 ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_3 0x54ba ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_4 0x54bb ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_PCIE_7 0x54be ADL-N PCIE
+product INTEL ADL_N_EMMC 0x54c4 ADL-N eMMC
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_4 0x54c5 ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_5 0x54c6 ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_UART_2 0x54c7 ADL-N UART
+product INTEL ADL_N_HDA0x54c8 ADL-N HDA
+product INTEL ADL_N_THC_0 0x54d0 ADL-N THC
+product INTEL ADL_N_THC_1 0x54d1 ADL-N THC
+product INTEL ADL_N_AHCI 0x54d3 ADL-N AHCI
+product INTEL ADL_N_UART_3 0x54da ADL-N UART
+product INTEL ADL_N_HECI_1 0x54e0 ADL-N HECI
+product INTEL ADL_N_HECI_2 0x54e1 ADL-N HECI
+product INTEL ADL_N_HECI_3 0x54e4 ADL-N HECI
+product INTEL ADL_N_HECI_4 0x54e5 ADL-N HECI
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_0 0x54e8 ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_1 0x54e9 ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_2 0x54ea ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_I2C_3 0x54eb ADL-N I2C
+product INTEL ADL_N_XHCI 0x54ed ADL-N xHCI
+product INTEL ADL_N_XDCI 0x54ee ADL-N xDCI
+product INTEL ADL_N_SRAM 0x54ef ADL-N SRAM
product INTEL WL_22500_16 0x54f0 Wi-Fi 6 AX211
+product INTEL ADL_N_GSPI_2 0x54fb ADL-N GSPI
+product INTEL ADL_N_UFS0x54ff ADL-N UFS
product INTEL I225_LMVP0x5502 I225-LMvP
product INTEL I226_K 0x5504 I226-K
product INTEL I219_LM180x550a I219-LM
Index: sys/dev/pci/ichiic.c
===
RCS file: /cvs/src/sys/dev/pci/ichiic.c,v
diff -u -p -r1.51 ichiic.c
--- sys/dev/pci/ichiic.c5 Feb 2023 02:26:02 - 1.51
+++ sys/dev/pci/ichiic.c23 Nov 2023 12:38:18 -
@@ -139,6 +139,7 @@ const struct pci_matchid ichiic_ids[] =
{ PCI_VENDOR_INTEL, PCI_PRODUCT_INTEL_700SERIES_SMB },
