Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Anthony Petrov
Hi Omair, The fix looks good to me. I think Kumar needs to take a look at it, too, before the fix can be pushed to a repo. Thanks for finding and fixing this issue. -- best regards, Anthony On 8/10/2012 1:48 AM, Omair Majid wrote: On 08/09/2012 07:15 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Kumar Srinivasan
Hi Anthony, a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide a regression test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, this would not have been removed during the RPATH work. We may have to check in a ".so" for linux and solaris variants. So my question

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Kumar Srinivasan
Hi Anthony, Omair, Shouldn't there be a case for MacOSX as well ? Kumar Hi Anthony, a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide a regression test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, this would not have been removed during the RPATH work. We may

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > On 08/09/2012 07:15 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: > > - Original Message - > >> Hi Kumar, > >> > >> On 07/23/2012 11:19 AM, Kumar Srinivasan wrote: > >>> My suggestion is to see if System.loadLibrary can be used, this > >>> will > >>> bode well for the modulariza

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > Hi Anthony, > > a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide > a > regression > test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, this would > not > have been removed > during the RPATH work. We may have to check in a ".so"

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Anthony Petrov
Hi Kumar, Omair, [ adding awt-dev@ in the loop ] On 8/10/2012 2:30 PM, Kumar Srinivasan wrote: a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide a regression test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, this would not have been removed during the RPATH work.

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Anthony Petrov
Well, it's complicated. There's problems with JAWT on the Mac currently, which makes it hard or even impossible to use it on that platform. We'll add support for the Mac to a test open-sourced with 7190587 once JAWT is working fine on the Mac in general. -- best regards, Anthony On 8/10/2012

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Anthony Petrov
On 8/10/2012 4:24 PM, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original Message - Hi Anthony, a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide a regression test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, this would not have been removed during the RPATH work. We m

Re: jdk builds on the mac

2012-08-10 Thread Erik Joelsson
Yes, that's what should be happening as I understand it. But right now, it's always the bootjdk. I also believe it's hardcoded to src and target 1.5. /Erik On 2012-08-10 14:17, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original Message - It does and I believe Joel, in the langtools team, is looking at

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > On 8/10/2012 4:24 PM, Andrew Hughes wrote: > > - Original Message - > >> Hi Anthony, > >> > >> a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to > >> provide > >> a > >> regression > >> test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin with, th

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Anthony Petrov
On 8/10/2012 4:59 PM, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original Message - On 8/10/2012 4:24 PM, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original Message - Hi Anthony, a. although this is a build change, I have requested Omair to provide a regression test, IMO if we had a regression test to begin w

Re: jdk builds on the mac

2012-08-10 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > It does and I believe Joel, in the langtools team, is looking at this > issue. > > /Erik > > On 2012-08-10 03:00, Kelly O'Hair wrote: > > I think we need to make sure that the only thing that gets built > > with the bootjdk javac is the langtools > > bootstrap javac

Re: jdk builds on the mac

2012-08-10 Thread Kelly O'Hair
On Aug 10, 2012, at 5:17 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: > - Original Message - >> It does and I believe Joel, in the langtools team, is looking at this >> issue. >> >> /Erik >> >> On 2012-08-10 03:00, Kelly O'Hair wrote: >>> I think we need to make sure that the only thing that gets built >>>

RFR: 7190512 Fix for 7181175 broke hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds.

2012-08-10 Thread Tim Bell
Hello all- After the fixes for 7181175 hit the hotspot-rt forest, users noticed that hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds were broken. This is a supplemental fix that restores building using that .bat file. Note that this is not on the 'product' build path at all - this is something HotSp

Re: RFR: 7190512 Fix for 7181175 broke hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds.

2012-08-10 Thread Daniel D. Daugherty
On 8/10/12 3:03 PM, Tim Bell wrote: Hello all- After the fixes for 7181175 hit the hotspot-rt forest, users noticed that hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds were broken. This is a supplemental fix that restores building using that .bat file. Note that this is not on the 'product' build p

Re: RFR: 7190512 Fix for 7181175 broke hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds.

2012-08-10 Thread Tim Bell
I wrote: Hello all- After the fixes for 7181175 hit the hotspot-rt forest, users noticed that hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds were broken. This is a supplemental fix that restores building using that .bat file. Note that this is not on the 'product' build path at all - this is somet

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Omair Majid
On 08/10/2012 08:20 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: >>> I built jdk8/build successfully just last week. What issues are >>> you seeing? >> >> Errors building hotspot, I seem to recall. But I cant reproduce it >> anymore after pulling today. I can now confirm that the fix works for >> me >> with jdk8 too.

Re: RFR: 7190512 Fix for 7181175 broke hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds.

2012-08-10 Thread Daniel D. Daugherty
On 8/10/12 3:07 PM, Tim Bell wrote: I wrote: Hello all- After the fixes for 7181175 hit the hotspot-rt forest, users noticed that hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds were broken. This is a supplemental fix that restores building using that .bat file. Note that this is not on the 'produc

Re: [PATCH] Update RPATH to make loading libjawt possible

2012-08-10 Thread Omair Majid
Hi Anthony, On 08/10/2012 08:29 AM, Anthony Petrov wrote: > Actually, if Omair has a good automatic jtreg test, we would be happy to > get it checked in with this fix. Could we see a webrev for the test please? I have uploaded a new webrev that includes a test case too: http://cr.openjdk.java.net

Re: RFR: 7190512 Fix for 7181175 broke hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds.

2012-08-10 Thread Tim Bell
On 08/10/12 14:08, Daniel D. Daugherty wrote: On 8/10/12 3:07 PM, Tim Bell wrote: I wrote: Hello all- After the fixes for 7181175 hit the hotspot-rt forest, users noticed that hotspot/make/windows/create.bat builds were broken. This is a supplemental fix that restores building using that .b