[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-25 Thread Chris Zach via cctalk
* Mr. Drill Press enter the chat * Mrs. Dectape laughs at your attempts :-) C :) g.

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-24 Thread Sellam Abraham via cctalk
On Fri, Mar 24, 2023 at 12:17 PM geneb via cctalk wrote: > On Fri, 24 Mar 2023, Tom Gardner via cctalk wrote: > > > Well the data are still there and could be retrieved with a > sophisticated servo on data system and/or a probe head on the data surfaces. > > Simpler to hit the spindle motor top

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-24 Thread Chuck Guzis via cctalk
On 3/24/23 12:17, geneb via cctalk wrote: > On Fri, 24 Mar 2023, Tom Gardner via cctalk wrote: > >> Well the data are still there and could be retrieved with a >> sophisticated servo on data system and/or a probe head on the data >> surfaces. >> Simpler to hit the spindle motor top dead center

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-24 Thread geneb via cctalk
On Fri, 24 Mar 2023, Tom Gardner via cctalk wrote: Well the data are still there and could be retrieved with a sophisticated servo on data system and/or a probe head on the data surfaces. Simpler to hit the spindle motor top dead center with a very large hammer ruining the bearings and

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-24 Thread Tom Gardner via cctalk
are still there so nothing beats a multi-pass full disk wipe -Original Message- From: Chris Zach [mailto:c...@beaker.crystel.com] Sent: Thursday, March 23, 2023 9:53 AM To: cctalk@classiccmp.org Subject: [cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone? Speaking from

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-24 Thread Chris Zach via cctalk
Speaking from experience with an old RD54, yep. Put a magnet on the outside case towards the bottom, spin the drive up and it's gone forever. On 3/23/2023 12:22 PM, Daniel Daigle via cctalk wrote: Old MFM/RLL drives with stepper positioners generally have no servo. The same can't be said of

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-03-23 Thread Daniel Daigle via cctalk
Old MFM/RLL drives with stepper positioners generally have no servo. The same can't be said of voice-coil positioned drives; they could use any means, including hardware optical servos, etc. but often used a surface and a head for that purpose... so yes, you can render one of these drives

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-05 Thread Tony Duell via cctalk
On Sun, Feb 5, 2023 at 11:12 AM emanuel stiebler via cctalk wrote: > Keep "all" magnets away from disks :) The hubs of 3.5" floppy disks and of the disk packs used in RK05s, RL01s/02s, RK07s, etc are locked to the spindle by a ring magnet. -tony

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-05 Thread emanuel stiebler via cctalk
On 2023-02-03 21:28, Chris Zach via cctalk wrote: Perm magnet. Those neodynium magnets are powerful, keep them away from disks. Keep "all" magnets away from disks :)

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-04 Thread Chris Zach via cctalk
Perm magnet. Those neodynium magnets are powerful, keep them away from disks. C On 2/3/2023 9:26 PM, Tom Hunter via cctalk wrote: Chris, what kind of magnet did you use? If it was an electromagnet I could imagine that you caused physical damage by something heating up sufficiently. If it was

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-04 Thread emanuel stiebler via cctalk
On 2023-02-03 11:57, Chris Zach via cctalk wrote: This is a Maxtor 2190. The RD54 base disk. I've been having major problems trying to format them on my RQDX3, I'll post that adventure in a bit. In a nutshell the drives only partially format then error out. On Dave G's MFM emulator all the

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Tom Hunter via cctalk
Chris, what kind of magnet did you use? If it was an electromagnet I could imagine that you caused physical damage by something heating up sufficiently. If it was a permanent magnet then it might indeed be servo data which has been erased. Either way I expect you need a very strong magnetic field

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Tony Duell via cctalk
On Fri, Feb 3, 2023 at 5:21 PM Alexandre Souza wrote: > > I thoug the right one was st512...can you enlighten me on this subject Tony? I've never heard it called that. It's often called 'ST506' but that drive had a few differences from the later ones. it didn't support buffered seeks AFAIK. The

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Adrian Godwin via cctalk
Or ST506 ? On Fri, Feb 3, 2023 at 5:21 PM Alexandre Souza via cctalk < cctalk@classiccmp.org> wrote: > I thoug the right one was st512...can you enlighten me on this subject > Tony? > > Enviado do meu Tele-Movel > > > > I assume by 'MFM' you mean a drive with an interface similar to the > ST412.

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Alexandre Souza via cctalk
I thoug the right one was st512...can you enlighten me on this subject Tony? Enviado do meu Tele-Movel > I assume by 'MFM' you mean a drive with an interface similar to the ST412. > -tony >

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Tony Duell via cctalk
On Fri, Feb 3, 2023 at 4:57 PM Chris Zach via cctalk wrote: > Yep, with 15 yeads it had a servo platter that is gone. Oh well, it's > securely erased :-) I'll toss the drive, keep the electronics interface > and keep it in mind for the future. If you have the tools, it's worth carefully

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Chris Zach via cctalk
Embedded servo is rare (unheard-of) on ST412 interfaced drives simply because the manufacturer has no idea how it will be low-level formatted and thus where the sector headers will be. So no safe place for the servo bursts on the data surfaces *nod* That's what I would think: MFM should allow

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Tony Duell via cctalk
On Fri, Feb 3, 2023 at 4:40 PM Chris Zach via cctalk wrote: > > Question: I just used a strong magnet to wipe an old Maxtor MFM drive > (magnet on outside of case). Now the drive will not even seek properly > on start up, just endlessly moves the heads.. > > Is the drive now toast? Do MFM drives

[cctalk] Re: Nuking an MFM drive with a magnet, format/servo gone?

2023-02-03 Thread Bill Degnan via cctalk
low level format On Fri, Feb 3, 2023 at 11:40 AM Chris Zach via cctalk wrote: > Question: I just used a strong magnet to wipe an old Maxtor MFM drive > (magnet on outside of case). Now the drive will not even seek properly > on start up, just endlessly moves the heads.. > > Is the drive now