On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Mark J. Blair
As long as we're talking philosophy, what do y'all think about emulating the TU58 drive, vs. emulating the TU58 *tape*? I cannot properly express my opinion of that tape cartridge design even if I violate list rules about use of profanity. But the drive itself isn't all that bad, aside from

RE: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread tony duell
As long as we're talking philosophy, what do y'all think about emulating the TU58 drive, vs. emulating the TU58 *tape*? I cannot properly express my opinion of that tape cartridge design even if I violate list rules about use of profanity. But the drive itself isn't all that bad,

RE: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread tony duell
That seems to me like it would be the trickiest part. The TU58 schematic appears to indicate that there are I think so. Of course you could cheat by making it a read-only tape. But I don't like that. separate erase head gaps (not on a separate head like in audio cassette drives), so

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Paul Koning
On Jun 16, 2015, at 12:10 PM, tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: As long as we're talking philosophy, what do y'all think about emulating the TU58 drive, vs. emulating the TU58 *tape*? I cannot properly express my opinion of that tape cartridge design even if I violate list

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Jun 16, 2015, at 09:10 , tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: You would, of course, not know which track it was reading, so you would have to output 2 blocks, one on each track, at once. And how would you detect it was writing? Look for an extra signal at the coupling head or

RE: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread tony duell
And yet another (possibly the most common one on computers) is to have a small drive wheel that pulls the tape at constant speed across the heads, and then have some other construction that drives the tape reels depending on tape tension or length. Think vacuum columns or spring loaded arms.

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Johnny Billquist
On 2015-06-16 19:51, tony duell wrote: And yet another (possibly the most common one on computers) is to have a small drive wheel that pulls the tape at constant speed across the heads, and then have some other construction that drives the tape reels depending on tape tension or length. Think

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Chuck Guzis
On 06/16/2015 11:08 AM, Henk Gooijen wrote: The round (approx 2 diameter) bearings of the TU80 do not rotate. Instead, the metal has tiny holes. Air pressure pushes the tape away from the bearings. As the tape moves, due to movement pressure, the tape comes closer to the air bearing. That is

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Chuck Guzis
On 06/16/2015 11:22 AM, Johnny Billquist wrote: Uh... The TU80/TU81 do not have vacuum columns... I didn't say that they did, Johnny. I said that the TU80 hails back to the vacuum-column CDC drive design of the 1960s. At least that's my understanding. --Chuck

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Johnny Billquist
On 2015-06-16 18:21, Paul Koning wrote: On Jun 16, 2015, at 12:10 PM, tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: As long as we're talking philosophy, what do y'all think about emulating the TU58 drive, vs. emulating the TU58 *tape*? I cannot properly express my opinion of that tape

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Henk Gooijen
-Oorspronkelijk bericht- From: Johnny Billquist Sent: Tuesday, June 16, 2015 7:31 PM To: cctalk@classiccmp.org Subject: Re: On the Emulation of TU58s [... snip ...] And then we have drives like the TU80/TU81 which do not seem to fit into any of the mentioned categories. I'm

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Johnny Billquist
On 2015-06-16 20:23, Mark J. Blair wrote: On Jun 16, 2015, at 11:22 , Johnny Billquist b...@update.uu.se wrote: Pretty much the standard CDC vacuum-column design since the 1960s. The TU80 is, after all, a CDC product. Two counter-rotating capstans--tape movement is determined by applying

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Jun 16, 2015, at 11:22 , Johnny Billquist b...@update.uu.se wrote: Pretty much the standard CDC vacuum-column design since the 1960s. The TU80 is, after all, a CDC product. Two counter-rotating capstans--tape movement is determined by applying positive or negative pressure to ether or

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Ian S. King
Mark, I've thought of that for my HP 9845, too. Sure would be nice to fabricate something that's flexible hardware that can be programmed for the peculiarities of various implementations. I'll put it on my list of things to do once I'm done with my dissertation. :-) On Tue, Jun 16, 2015 at

RE: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread tony duell
[Driving tape] Another solution is to avoid the problem entirely by not requiring constant linear speed. That’s what DECtape (the real one) does. Sure. A number of tape drives were built that way, the HP9865 (and thus the built-in tape drive on the HP9830) is another example. One is

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Johnny Billquist
On 2015-06-16 20:20, Chuck Guzis wrote: On 06/16/2015 11:08 AM, Henk Gooijen wrote: The round (approx 2 diameter) bearings of the TU80 do not rotate. Instead, the metal has tiny holes. Air pressure pushes the tape away from the bearings. As the tape moves, due to movement pressure, the tape

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Chuck Guzis
On 06/16/2015 01:54 PM, Brent Hilpert wrote: Once ran across a Honeywell drive (7-track) that had a 'vacuum capstan'. The capstan wheel had a vacuum path through the axle and then transferred the vacuum out to holes around the perimeter. So rather than a pinch roller or rubber frictional

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Henk Gooijen
-Oorspronkelijk bericht- From: Johnny Billquist Sent: Tuesday, June 16, 2015 8:22 PM To: cctalk@classiccmp.org Subject: Re: On the Emulation of TU58s On 2015-06-16 20:20, Chuck Guzis wrote: On 06/16/2015 11:08 AM, Henk Gooijen wrote: The round (approx 2 diameter) bearings

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Johnny Billquist
On 2015-06-16 21:20, tony duell wrote: And yet another (possibly the most common one on computers) is to have a small drive wheel that pulls the tape at constant speed across the heads, and then have some other construction that drives the tape reels depending on tape tension or length. Think

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Brent Hilpert
On 2015-Jun-16, at 12:31 PM, Paul Koning wrote: On Jun 16, 2015, at 3:20 PM, tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: ... The actual tape movement as such, is all done by the small wheel next to the head, which just runs the tape past the head. Which is essentailly the same as the capstan

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Jun 16, 2015, at 09:10 , tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: Incidentally, given the fact that a constant motor speed - constant tape speed, it should be possible to make a device to put the timing track on a blank tape for the TU58. Has anyone done that? There's no timing

RE: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread tony duell
And yet another (possibly the most common one on computers) is to have a small drive wheel that pulls the tape at constant speed across the heads, and then have some other construction that drives the tape reels depending on tape tension or length. Think vacuum columns or spring loaded

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Eric Smith
Johnny Billquist wrote: Then you can figure out tape speed across the heads (if you care) by just observing flux changes. Tony Duell wrote: Only if there is something on the tape. These computer tape drives could surely record on a totally blank tape and get the right number of bits per

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Chuck Guzis
On 06/16/2015 11:30 AM, Henk Gooijen wrote: well, the tiny space between the tape and the air bearing could be regarded a vacuum column, but it's a very short one :-) The two air bearings are immediately above and below the R/W and erase head. And they do *not* rotate. The tape glides on an air

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Paul Koning
On Jun 16, 2015, at 3:20 PM, tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: ... The actual tape movement as such, is all done by the small wheel next to the head, which just runs the tape past the head. Which is essentailly the same as the capstan in an audio tape recorder, albeit the

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Mark J. Blair
On Jun 16, 2015, at 12:46 , tony duell a...@p850ug1.demon.co.uk wrote: For something even madder, look at the design of the original Radio Shack 'Line Printer' which was actually a Centronics something-pr-other (733?). This thing (which is not a line printer at all) has a belt running

Re: On the Emulation of TU58s

2015-06-16 Thread Paul Koning
On Jun 16, 2015, at 3:48 PM, Eric Smith space...@gmail.com wrote: Johnny Billquist wrote: Then you can figure out tape speed across the heads (if you care) by just observing flux changes. Tony Duell wrote: Only if there is something on the tape. These computer tape drives could surely